← Index Overview
Supreme Court

2025-002104

Supreme Court
C-Track →
Decision Filed

John A. Tibbs v. Asbestos Corporation Limited (15)

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal Richland (2023CP4001759)
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2025-10-14
Case Type Common Pleas Case Subtype Other
Filed Date 2025-10-14 Argument Date 2026-02-25
Disposition Date 2026-05-27 Remittitur Date —
Last Action Event 2026-05-27
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2025-10-14 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Altrad)
Notice of Appeal Order (10/13/25) Email from Counsel Filing Fee
2 2025-10-14 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Charter Cons.)
Notice of Appeal Order (10/13/25) Email from Counsel Filing Fee
3 2025-10-15 Motion - Respondent's Motion to Dismiss
Motion to Dismiss Email from Counsel Filing Fee
4 2025-10-20 Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Respondent's Motion to Dismiss
Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Respondent\'s Motion to Dismiss Email to Counsel
5 2025-11-04 Rehearing - Appellants' Petition for Rehearing (Altrad)
Petition for Rehearing Attachment A Attachment B Email from Counsel Filing Fee
6 2025-11-04 Rehearing - Appellants' Petition for Rehearing (Charter Cons.)
Petition for Rehearing Email from Counsel Filing fee
7 2025-11-06 Motion - Strike
Motion to Strike Email Filing fee
8 2025-11-10 Correspondence - Outgoing (Request for Return to Petitions for Rehearing)
Request for Return Email to Counsel
9 2025-11-14 Motion - Motion to Hold Deadline in Abeyance
Motion Email Filing Fee
10 2025-11-17 Motion - Return to Motion to Strike (Altrad)
Return to Motion to Strike Email from Counsel
11 2025-11-17 Motion - Return to Motion to Strike (ESAB)
Return to Motion to Strike Email from Counsel
12 2025-11-20 Rehearing - Return
Return to Rehearing Proof of Service Cover Email
13 2025-11-20 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Certifying To Supreme Court
Order
14 2025-11-20 Transfer - To Supreme Court
—
15 2025-11-26 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Court's Order)
Response Proof of Service Cover Email
16 2025-11-26 Non-Dispositional Decision - Briefing Schedule
Briefing Schedule Order Cover Email
17 2025-12-10 Final Brief - Appellant (Altrad)(10 copies)
Final Brief - Appellant (Altrad) Proof of Service Cover Email
18 2025-12-10 Record - Record on Appeal Filed
Record on Appeal I Record on Appeal 2 Record on Appeal 3 Record on Appeal 4 Record on Appeal 5 Record on Appeal 6 Record on Appeal 7 Record on Appeal 8 Record on Appeal 9 Record on Appeal 10
19 2025-12-10 Final Brief - Appellant (Charter) (10 copies)
Final Brief - Appellant (Charter) Proof of Service Cover Email
20 2025-12-23 Motion - Clarification on Briefing Schedule and Citations to Supplemental Record on Appeal (6day extension)
Motion Cover Letter Cover Email
21 2025-12-29 Motion - Return
Return Proof of Service Cover Email
22 2025-12-30 Final Brief - Respondent (Tibbs Final Response Brief)(10 copies)
Final Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Cover Email
23 2025-12-30 Record - Final Appendix To Record on Appeal (6 copies)
Final Appendix To Record on Appeal Proof of Service Cover Email
24 2025-12-30 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae
Motion (Appear as Amicus Curiae) Cover Email
25 2025-12-30 Brief - Amicus (Motley Rice, LLC et al.)(10 copies)
Brief-Amicus (Motley Rice, LLC et al.)
26 2025-12-30 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Cape)
Designation of Matter Filed (Cape) Proof of Service Cover Email
27 2025-12-31 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Clarification on Briefing Schedule and Citations to Supplemental Record on Appeal (6day extension)
Order Granting Motion - Clarification on Briefing Schedule and Citations to Supplemental Record on Appeal (6day extension)
28 2026-01-05 Record - Supplemental (6 copies)
Email Record on Appeal Vol. 11 Record on Appeal Vol. 12 Record on Appeal Vol. 13 Record on Appeal Vol. 14 Record on Appeal Vol. 15 Record on Appeal Vol. 16 Record on Appeal Vol. 17 Record on Appeal Vol. 18 Record on Appeal Vol. 19 Record on Appeal Vol. 20 Record on Appeal Vol. 21 Cover Letter
29 2026-01-05 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter re: Expedited Oral Argument)
Letter re: Expedited Oral Argument Cover Email
30 2026-01-06 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notification to counsel of bound copies needed)
Email
31 2026-01-06 Final Brief - Reply (Altrad)(10 copies)
Final Reply Brief (Altrad) Proof of Service Cover Email
32 2026-01-06 Final Brief - Reply (Charter)(10 copies)
Final Brief - Reply (Charter) Proof of Service Cover Email
33 2026-01-09 Final Brief - Respondent (Cape LLC)(AMENDED)(6 copies)
Amended Final Respondent\'s Brief (Cape, LLC) Proof of Service Cover Email
34 2026-01-12 Final Brief - Briefing and Record Complete
—
35 2026-01-22 Correspondence - Outgoing (Time Limit Letter)
Time Limit Letter
36 2026-01-28 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion for Amicus
Order
37 2026-01-30 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh, PA)
Motion to Appear Amicus (NUFICP) Proof of Service Cover Email
38 2026-01-30 Brief - Amicus (National Union Fire Insurance)(6 Copies)
Amicus Brief (NUFICP) Proof of Service
39 2026-01-30 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (New-Indy Containerboard, LLC)
Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (New-Indy Containerboard, LLC) Proof of Service Cover Email
40 2026-01-30 Brief - Amicus (New-Indy Containerboard, LLC)(6 copies)
Amicus Brief (New-Indy) Proof of Service Cover Email Copy filed 2/6
41 2026-02-04 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Amicus
Order
42 2026-02-04 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Amicus
Order
43 2026-02-06 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (Santa Fe Braun, et al.)
Motion Proof of Service Cover Letter Cover Email
44 2026-02-06 Brief - Amicus (Santa Fe Braun, et al.)(6 copies)
Amicus Brief (Santa Fe Braun, et al.) Proof of Service
45 2026-02-09 Brief - Charter's Amicus Reply to Motley Rice, LLC, et al. Amicus Brief (6 copies)
Amicus Reply (Charter\'s Amicus Reply to Motley Rice) Proof of Service Cover Email
46 2026-02-09 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Amicus Motion
Order
47 2026-02-09 Brief - Altrad's Reply to Motley Rice, LLC, et al. Amicus Brief (6 copies)
Amicus Reply Proof of Service Cover Email
48 2026-02-10 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (Asbestos Victims)
Motion to Appear Amicus (Asbestos Victims) Proof of Service
49 2026-02-10 Brief - Amicus (Asbestos Victims)(6 copies)
Brief - Amicus (Asbestos Victims) Cover Email Proof of Service
50 2026-02-11 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae (Beattie B. Ashmore)
Motion to Appear Amicus (Beattie B. Ashmore) Cover Email Proof of Service
51 2026-02-11 Brief - Amicus (Beattie B. Ashmore)(6 copies)
Amicus Brief (Beattie B. Ashmore) Proof of Service
52 2026-02-12 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Amicus for Asbestos Victims
Order
53 2026-02-12 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Amicus for Beattie B. Ashmore
Order
54 2026-02-12 Correspondence - Incoming (THEILE MCVEY arguing for Respondents (Tibbs))
Email
55 2026-02-12 Correspondence - Incoming (VICTOR RAWL arguing for Appellants)
Email
56 2026-02-12 Correspondence - Incoming (TODD CARROLL presenting for Altrad (Appellant))
Email
57 2026-02-13 Brief - Amicus Reply (From Receiver in Response to NUFI)(6 copies)
Amicus Reply (From Receiver in Response to NUFI) Proof of Service Cover Email
58 2026-02-17 Brief - Amicus Reply (From Altrad in Response to New-Indy)
Altrad\'s Amicus Reply to New-Indy Proof of Service Cover Email
59 2026-02-17 Brief - Amicus Reply (From Charter in Response to New-Indy)(6 copies)
Charter\'s Amicus Reply to New-Indy Proof of Service Cover Email
60 2026-02-17 Correspondence - Incoming (JOHN T. LAY arguing for Receiver/Respondents)
Email
61 2026-02-19 Brief - Amicus Reply (Joint Altrad and Charter in Response to Santa Fe Braun, et al)(6 copies)
Amicus Reply (Joint Altrad and Charter) Proof of Service Cover Email
62 2026-02-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Amicus Support from The Forestry Association of South Carolina)
Letter Cover Email
63 2026-02-23 Brief - Amicus Reply (Charter and Altrad's Response to Beattie Ashmore)
Amicus Reply (Response to Beattie Ashmore) Proof of Service
64 2026-02-23 Brief - Amicus Reply (Charter and Altrad's Response to Asbestos Victims)
Amicus Reply (Response to Asbestos Victims) Proof of Service
65 2026-02-25 Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
—
66 2026-03-25 Correspondence - Incoming (Motion Challenging Subject Matter Jurisdiction and Fraud filed by Fink and Kennedy)
Motion Signature Page Cover Email
67 2026-03-26 Supplemental Citations - Received (Appellant)
Supplemental Citations Notice of Hearing 2nd Amended Summons Cover Email
68 2026-03-27 Correspondence - Outgoing (No Action Letter)
Letter
69 2026-03-27 Supplemental Citations - Response (Respondent)
Response to Supplemental Citations Attachments Cover Email
70 2026-03-27 Supplemental Citations - Response (Receiver)
Response to Supplemental Citations Attachment Cover Email
71 2026-03-30 Supplemental Citations - Reply to Letters in Opposition to Supplemental Citations
Reply to Return to Supp. Citations Exhibit 1 Exhibit 2 Cover Email
72 2026-04-30 Supplemental Citations - Received (Second)
Second Supplemental Citations Attachment 1 Attachment 2 Cover Email
73 2026-05-08 Supplemental Citations - Received (Third)
Supplemental Citations - Received (Third) Attachments Cover Email
74 2026-05-14 Supplemental Citations - Response
Letter Attachment Cover Email
75 2026-05-15 Correspondence - Incoming (Altrad Letter and Copy of Park Order)
Correspondence Order Cover Email
76 2026-05-27 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Op. 28337 Tibbs v. Asbestos Corp. Limited (15).pdf