← Index Overview
Court of Appeals

2023-001401

Court of Appeals
C-Track →
Remittitur

Natalie Zitek v. D.R. Horton, Inc. (1)

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal Anderson (2019CP0401942)
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2023-09-06
Case Type Common Pleas Case Subtype Other
Filed Date 2023-09-06 Argument Date 2026-02-03
Disposition Date 2026-04-08 Remittitur Date 2026-04-28
Last Action Event 2026-05-15
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2023-09-06 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial
Notice of Appeal Order (August 16, 2023) Order (July 28, 2023) Order (August 07, 2023) Order (July 28, 2023) Order (August 23, 2023) Order (July 19, 2023) Order (February 16, 2023) Order (May 08, 2023) Order (August 17, 2023) Email NOA Fee
2 2023-09-06 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Jason M. Imhoff for D.R. Horton, Inc.)
Notice of Appearance
3 2023-09-06 Motion - Stay / Supersedeas (including lifting of automatic stay)
Motion to Stay Motion Fee
4 2023-09-07 Motion - Return (Motion to Stay)
Return to Motion Email
5 2023-09-08 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Regarding Respondents)
Letter
6 2023-09-08 Motion - Reply (Motion for Supersedeas)
Reply Email from Counsel
7 2023-09-11 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Helen Hiser for Respondent M&L Reyna Construction, LLC)
Notice of Appearance
8 2023-09-11 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
Transcript Ordered Transcript Ordered (2) Transcript Ordered (3) Transcript Ordered (4) Transcript Ordered (5) Transcript Ordered (6) Transcript Ordered (7) Email (1) Email (2) Email (3) Email (4) Email (5)
9 2023-09-12 Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence
Email Email (2)
10 2023-09-12 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Regarding Respondents)
Letter
11 2023-09-14 Motion - Stay / Supersedeas (Helen Hiser, Counsel for M&L Reyna Construction, LLC)
Motion - Stay / Supersedeas (Helen Hiser, Counsel for M&L Reyna Construction, LLC) E-Mail Original
12 2023-09-14 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
Transcript Ordered Email
13 2023-09-15 Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Letter to Withdraw Supersedeas)
Letter Email
14 2023-09-15 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter to Withdraw Respondent's Supersedeas)
Letter Email
15 2023-09-19 Non-Dispositional Decision - Withdrawn or Ended (Both Motions for Supersedeas Withdrawn)
Letter Email
16 2023-10-24 Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence (Correspondence with Court Reporter)
Email
17 2023-10-26 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Timothy Newton for Respondent Installed Building Products)
Notice of Appearance Email
18 2023-10-27 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Transfer Within Firm for Defendant)
Letter
19 2023-12-05 Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence
Transcript Correspondence (1) Transcript Correspondence (2) Transcript Correspondence (3) Transcript Correspondence (4)
20 2024-01-10 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Alicia N. Bolyard for Respondent Builders Services Group, Inc.)
Letter
21 2024-01-10 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Nosizi Ralephata for Respondent Builders Services Group, Inc.)
Notice of Appearance
22 2024-01-10 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Regarding Caption)
Letter Email
23 2024-01-22 Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (N. Keith Emge, Jr., Esq and Jessica W. Stratta, Esq)
Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (N. Keith Emge, Jr., Esq and Jessica W. Stratta, Esq) Email from Counsel Filing Fee
24 2024-01-30 Correspondence - Outgoing (Court's Request for Clarification)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Court\'s Request for Clarification) Email to Counsel
25 2024-02-05 Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Response Correspondence - Outgoing (Court's Request for Clarification))
Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s Response Correspondence - Outgoing (Court\'s Request for Clarification)) Email from Counsel
26 2024-02-07 Correspondence - Incoming (Timothy J. Newton, Esq Response to Correspondence - Outgoing (Court's Response to Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Response Correspondence - Outgoing (Court's Request for Clarification)))) and Clarification of Representation
Correspondence - Incoming (Timothy J. Newton, Esq Response to Correspondence - Outgoing (Court\'s Response to Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s Re
27 2024-02-07 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal Initial Letter) Email to Counsel
28 2024-02-07 Correspondence - Outgoing (Court's Response to Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Response Correspondence - Outgoing (Court's Request for Clarification)))
Correspondence - Outgoing (Court\'s Response to Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s Response Correspondence - Outgoing (Court\'s Request for Clarific Email to Counsel
29 2024-02-07 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (N. Keith Emge, Jr., Esq and Jessica W. Stratta, Esq)
Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (N. Keith Emge, Jr., Esq and Jessica W. Stratta, Esq) Email to Counsel
30 2024-02-08 Initial Brief - Appellant
Initial Brief - Appellant Proof of Service
31 2024-02-08 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed Email from Counsel
32 2024-02-13 Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence- Respondent Order Transcript
Transcript Documents - Additional Transcript Ordered
33 2024-02-13 Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence
Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence
34 2024-02-13 Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence- Email from Respondent Assistant
Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence- Email from Respondent Assistant
35 2024-02-14 Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence Email from Respondent Assistant
Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence Email from Respondent Assistant
36 2024-02-14 Transcript Documents - Transcript
—
37 2024-02-28 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent's (IBA Assets)
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent\'s (IBA Assets) Email from Counsel with note about filing fee
38 2024-02-28 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent's (Builders Services Group)
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent\'s (Builders Services Group) Email from Counsel with note about filing fee
39 2024-03-01 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
40 2024-03-01 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent's (IBA Assets))
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent\'s (IBA Assets))
41 2024-03-01 Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence- Respondent Order Transcript
Transcript Documents - Other Correspondence- Respondent Order Transcript Email from Counsel
42 2024-03-05 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent's (Builders Services Group))
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent\'s (Builders Services Group))
43 2024-04-10 Initial Brief - Respondent (IBP Assets, LLC)
Initial Brief - Respondent (IBP Assets, LLC)
44 2024-04-10 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed Email from Counsel
45 2024-04-10 Initial Brief - Respondent (Builder Services Group)
Initial Brief - Respondent (Builder Services Group)
46 2024-04-10 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed Email from Counsel
47 2024-04-12 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant's Reply Brief
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant\'s Reply Brief Email from Counsel Filing Fee 04.15.24
48 2024-04-15 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
49 2024-04-15 Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent IBP Assets Advising Representation)
Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent IBP Assets Advising Representation)
50 2024-04-19 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant's Reply Brief)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant\'s Reply Brief
51 2024-05-13 Stricken Initial Brief - Reply to Respondent Builder Services Group
Initial Brief - Reply to Respondent Builder Services Group Proof of Service
52 2024-05-13 Items Stricken- Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
—
53 2024-05-13 Stricken Initial Brief - Reply to IBP Assets, LLC
Proof of Service
54 2024-06-03 Correspondence - Outgoing (Bound Copy Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Bound Copy Letter) Email to Counsel
55 2024-06-12 Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
—
56 2024-06-12 Record - Record on Appeal Filed
—
57 2024-06-12 Builder Services Group's Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent's Email Regarding Representation)
Builder Services Group\'s Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent\'s Email Regarding Representation) Builder Services Group\'s Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent\'s Email Regarding Representation) 2 Email from Counsel
58 2024-06-12 Joint Respondents' Motion - Strike
Joint Respondents\' Motion - Strike Email from Counsel with note about filing fee
59 2024-06-13 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Joint Respondents' Motion - Strike)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Joint Respondents\' Motion - Strike)
60 2024-06-20 Motion - Return
Motion - Return Email from Counsel
61 2024-06-25 Motion - Reply
Motion - Reply Email from Counsel
62 2024-06-28 Respondent's Motion - Regarding Final Briefs (Final Briefs to be Stayed) (IBP Assets)
Respondent\'s Motion - Regarding Final Briefs (Final Briefs to be Stayed) (IBP Assets) Email from Counsel with note about filing fee
63 2024-07-01 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Respondent's Motion - Regarding Final Briefs (Final Briefs to be Stayed) (IBP Assets))
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Respondent\'s Motion - Regarding Final Briefs (Final Briefs to be Stayed) (IBP Assets))
64 2024-07-01 Stricken Final Brief - Reply to IBP
Email from Counsel
65 2024-07-01 Stricken Final Brief - Reply to Respondent Gale
Email from Counsel
66 2024-07-01 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent's (Builder Services Group) Final Brief
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent\'s (Builder Services Group) Final Brief Email from Counsel with note about filing fee Filing Fee
67 2024-07-02 Final Brief - Respondent (IBP Assets)
Email from Counsel
68 2024-07-02 Final Brief - Appellant
Final Brief - Appellant Proof of Service Email from Counsel
69 2024-07-02 Correspondence - Outgoing (To Hold in Abeyance)
Correspondence - Outgoing (To Hold in Abeyance) Email to Counsel
70 2024-07-09 Appellant's Supplemental Citations - Received
Supplemental Citations - Received Email from Counsel
71 2024-07-09 Respondent's Supplemental Citations - Received (IBP)
Respondent\'s Supplemental Citations - Received (IBP) Email to Counsel
72 2024-07-10 Supplemental Citations - Received (Builder Services Group) (Revised)
Supplemental Citations - Received (Builder Services Group) Revised Email from Counsel Revised
73 2024-08-23 Stricken-Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion to Strike and File Supplemental Record on Appeal - Granted)
Order Email to Counsel
74 2024-09-04 Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent's Request for Clarification)
Correspondence - Incoming (Respondents\' Request for Clarification) Email from Counsel
75 2024-09-06 Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Response to Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent's Request for Clarification))
Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s Response to Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent\'s Request for Clarification)) Email from Counsel
76 2024-09-06 Initial Revised Brief - Reply Brief of Appellant Replying to Respondent Gale
Initial Revised Brief - Reply Brief of Appellant Replying to Respondent Gale Email from Counsel
77 2024-09-06 Initial Revised Brief - Reply Brief of Appellant Replying to IBP
Initial Revised Brief - Reply Brief of Appellant Replying to IBP Email from Counsel 1
78 2024-09-06 Revised Designation of Matter - Supplemental
Revised Designation of Matter - Supplemental Email from Counsel
79 2024-09-10 Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent's Reply to Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Response to Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent's Request for Clarification)))
Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent\'s Reply to Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s Response to Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent\'s Request fo Email from Counsel
80 2024-09-13 Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
81 2024-09-13 Amended Record - Record on Appeal Filed
Record on Appeal Vol 1 Record on Appeal Vol 2 Record on Appeal Vol 3 Record on Appeal Vol 4
82 2024-09-13 Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent's (Builder Services Group) Letter Regarding Representation)
Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent\'s (Builder Services Group) Letter Regarding Representation)
83 2024-09-16 Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Response to Respondent IBP Asset, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products Reply and Modified Request for Clarification)
Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s Response to Respondent IBP Asset, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products Reply and Modified Request for Clarifi Attachments Email from Counsel Email from Counsel 2
84 2024-09-17 Correspondence - Incoming (Surreply to Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Response to Respondent IBP Asset, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products Reply and Modified Request for Clarification))
Correspondence - Incoming (Surreply to Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s Response to Respondent IBP Asset, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products Email from Counsel
85 2024-09-17 Correspondence - Incoming (Builder Services Group) (Letter Regarding Request for Clarification)
Correspondence - Incoming (Builder Services Group) (Letter Regarding Request for Clarification) Email from Counsel
86 2024-09-20 Final Brief - Respondent (Builder Services Group)
Final Brief - Respondent (Builder Services Group) Email from Counsel
87 2024-09-23 Respondent's IBP Assets, LLC Record - Supplemental
Record - Supplemental
88 2024-09-23 Amended Final Brief - Respondent (IBP Assets)
Amended Final Brief - Respondent (IBP Assets) Email from Counsel
89 2024-09-30 Correspondence - Incoming (Parties Email Thread Regarding Storm and Potential Delays)
Correspondence - Incoming (Parties Email Regarding Storm and Potential Delays)
90 2024-10-18 Appellant's Motion - Hold in Abeyance Pending A Decision on IBP Assest, LLC's D/B/A Blue Ridge Building Products' Request for Clarification
Appellant\'s Motion - Hold in Abeyance Pending A Decision on IBP Assest, LLC\'s D/B/A Blue Ridge Building Products\' Request for Clarification Email from Counsel Email Regarding Filing Fee
91 2024-10-21 Motion - Return
Motion - Return Email from Counsel
92 2024-10-21 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Joint Respondents' Motion - Strike
Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Joint Respondents\' Motion - Strike Email to Counsel
93 2024-10-29 Appellant's Motion - Strike Portions of the Briefs of Respondent's IBP Assets, LLC D/B/A Blue Ridge Building Products and Gale Industries, Inc.
Appellant\'s (D.R. Horton, Inc.) Motion - Strike Portions of the Briefs of Respondent\'s IBP Assets, LLC D/B/A Blue Ridge Building Products and Gale Ind Filing Fee Email from Counsel
94 2024-11-04 Revised Initial Brief - Reply Brief of Appellant Replying to Respondent Gale
Revised Initial Brief - Reply Brief of Appellant Replying to Respondent Gale Proof of Service Email from Counsel
95 2024-11-04 Revised Initial Brief - Reply Brief of Appellant Replying to IBP
Revised Initial Brief - Reply Brief of Appellant Replying to IBP Email from Counsel Proof of Service
96 2024-11-04 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed Email from Counsel Proof of Service
97 2024-11-08 Joint Respondent's Motion - Strike
Joint Respondent\'s Motion - Strike Email from Counsel Proof of Service Amended Joint Respondent\'s Motion - Strike Email from Counsel
98 2024-11-08 Motion - Return to Appellant's Motion to Strike
Motion - Return
99 2024-11-13 Motion - Reply to Return to Appellant's Motion to Strike
Motion - Reply to Return to Appellant\'s Motion to Strike Email from Counsel
100 2024-11-18 Appellant's Motion - Return to Respondent's Cross Motion to Strike
Appellant\'s Motion - Return to Respondent\'s Cross Motion to Strike Email from Counsel
101 2024-11-21 Respondent's Motion - Reply Memorandum in Support of Their Cross-Motion to Strike or, in The Alternative, Motion to Allow Supplemental Briefing
Respondent\'s Motion - Reply Memorandum in Support of Their Cross-Motion to Strike or, in The Alternative, Motion to Allow Supplemental Briefing Email from Counsel
102 2024-12-02 Appellant's Record - Supplemental
Appellant\'s Record - Supplemental Proof of Service Email from Counsel Cover Letter
103 2024-12-04 Correspondence - Outgoing (To Hold in Abeyance)
Correspondence - Outgoing (To Hold in Abeyance) Email to Counsel
104 2025-02-12 Respondent's Supplemental Citations - Received (IBP Assets, LLC)
Respondent\'s Supplemental Citations - Received (IBP Assets, LLC) Email from Counsel
105 2025-04-24 Supplemental Citations - Response
Supplemental Citations - Response Email from Counsel
106 2025-05-23 Respondent's Supplemental Citations - Received (IBP Assets, LLC)
Respondent\'s Supplemental Citations - Received (IBP Assets, LLC) Email from Counsel
107 2025-06-05 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter) Email to Counsel
108 2025-06-09 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Newton - not 10/15-16 Bolyard - no conflicts
109 2025-07-08 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order for Respondents to Remove Stricken Material and Amend and to File Final Sur-reply
Non-Dispositional Decision - Order for Respondents to Remove Stricken Material and Amend and to File Final Sur-reply Email to Counsel
110 2025-07-09 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter) Email to Counsel
111 2025-07-15 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) File Sur-Reply Briefs
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) File Sur-Reply Briefs Email from Counsel
112 2025-07-18 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
113 2025-08-11 Amended Final Brief - Respondent IBP Assets, LLC d/b/a Blue Ride Building Products per July 8, 2025 Order
Amended Final Brief - Respondent IBP Assets, LLC d/b/a Blue Ride Building Products per July 8, 2025 Order Email from Counsel
114 2025-08-12 Final Brief - Respondent (Builder Services Group d/b/a Gale Contractor Services)
Final Brief - Respondent (Builder Services Group d/b/a Gale Contractor Services) Email from Counsel Duplicate Final Brief - Respondent (Builder Services Group d/b/a Gale Contractor Services) Duplicate Email from Counsel
115 2025-09-08 Joint Final Brief - Sur-Reply of Respondents IBP Assets, LLC Builder Services Group
Joint Final Brief - Sur-Reply of Respondents IBP Assets, LLC Builder Services Group Email from Counsel
116 2025-09-11 Correspondence - Outgoing (6 Bound Copy)
Correspondence - Outgoing (6 Bound Copy) Email to Counsel
117 2025-09-22 Final Brief - Reply (Gale)
Final Brief - Reply (Gale) Proof of Service Email from Counsel
118 2025-09-22 Final Brief - Reply (IBP)
Final Brief - Reply (IBP) Proof of Service Email from Counsel
119 2025-10-06 Correspondence - Outgoing - Conflict Letter for Oral Argument
Conflict Letter
120 2025-10-08 Appellant's Motion - Strike Surreply Brief of Respondents IMP Assets, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products and Gale Industries, Inc.
Appellant\'s Motion - Strike Surreply Brief of Respondents IMP Assets, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products and Gale Industries, Inc. Email from Counsel
121 2025-10-16 Respondents' Motion - Return
Respondents\' Motion - Return Email from Counsel
122 2025-10-21 Appellant's Motion - Reply in Support of it's Motion to Strike the Surreply Brief of Respondent IBP Assets, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products and Gale Industries, Inc.
Appellant\'s Motion - Reply in Support of it\'s Motion to Strike the Surreply Brief of Respondent IBP Assets, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products and Email from Counsel
123 2025-11-21 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter Concerning Motion to Strike)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter Concerning Motion to Strike)
124 2026-01-05 Correspondence - Outgoing (Oral Argument Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Oral Argument Letter) Email to Counsel
125 2026-01-12 Correspondence - Outgoing (Change in time of oral argument)
Email to Counsel
126 2026-02-03 Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
—
127 2026-04-08 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
26-UP-172 - Natalie Zitek v. D.R. Horton, Inc. (1).docx Cover Letter Email to Counsel
128 2026-04-28 Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
Remittitur - Remittitur Sent Email to Counsel
129 2026-05-12 Respondent's Motion - Costs (Builder Services Group, Inc. d/b/a Gale Contractor Services Memorandum in Support of Motion
Respondent\'s Motion - Costs (Builder Services Group, Inc. d/b/a Gale Contractor Services Memorandum in Support of Motion with note about filing fee Itemized Statement of Costs Email from Counsel
130 2026-05-13 Respondent's Motion - Costs (IBP Asset, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products)
Respondent\'s Motion - Costs (IBP Asset, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products) Itemized Statement of Costs Email from Counsel Mailed Copy of Respondent\'s Motion - Costs (IBP Asset, LLC d/b/a Blue Ridge Building Products) 05.15 Mailed Copy of Itemized Statement of Costs 05.15
131 2026-05-15 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Notarization)
Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Notarization) Email to Counsel