← Index Overview
Court of Appeals

2023-001351

Court of Appeals
C-Track →
Remittitur

Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League v. SCDES

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal 2022ALJ070131CC
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2023-08-23
Case Type Administrative Law Court Case Subtype Administrative Law Court
Filed Date 2023-08-23 Argument Date 2025-06-24
Disposition Date 2026-01-28 Remittitur Date 2026-02-13
Last Action Event 2026-04-21
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2023-08-23 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial
Notice of Appeal, POS, Coverletter with note about filing fee Order Under Appeal Email from Counsel Filing Fee
2 2023-08-28 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal Initial Letter) Email to Counsel
3 2023-08-28 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial)
4 2023-09-18 Correspondence - Outgoing (Transcript Overdue Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Transcript Overdue Letter) Email to Counsel
5 2023-09-18 Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (Lauren M. Milton and Benjamin D. Cunningham) and Extension of Time of Initial Brief of Appellant
Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (Lauren M. Milton and Benjamin D. Cunningham) and Extension of Time of Initial Brief of Appellant Email from Counsel with note about filing fee Proof of Service 09.22.23 corrected
6 2023-09-18 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered Email from Counsel
7 2023-09-22 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Proof of Service on Client)
Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Proof of Service on Client) Email to Counsel
8 2023-09-22 Deficiency - Correction
Deficiency - Correction Email from Counsel Mailed Copy of Deficiency - Correction 09.27
9 2023-11-20 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (Lauren M. Milton and Benjamin D. Cunningham)
Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (Lauren M. Milton and Benjamin D. Cunningham) Email to Counsel
10 2023-11-21 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance)
Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance)
11 2023-11-22 Correspondence - Outgoing (Transcript Overdue Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Transcript Overdue Letter) Email to Counsel
12 2023-11-30 Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal
Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal Email from Counsel
13 2023-11-30 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant's Initial Brief
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant\'s Initial Brief with note about filing fee Email from Counsel
14 2023-12-04 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant's Initial Brief)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant\'s Initial Brief)
15 2023-12-06 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
16 2023-12-11 Motion - Stay / Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing
Motion - Stay / Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing
17 2023-12-12 Correspondence - Outgoing (Return Requested)
return requested
18 2023-12-13 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Stay / Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Stay / Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing)
19 2023-12-19 Motion - Return (SCDHEC)
Motion - Return (SCDHEC) E-Mail E-Mail 2
20 2023-12-22 Motion - Return (Dominion) to Motion - Stay / Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing
Motion - Return (Dominion) to Motion - Stay / Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing Email from Counsel
21 2023-12-27 Correspondence - Incoming (Cover Letter to Motion - Return (Dominion))
Correspondence - Incoming (Cover Letter to Motion - Return (Dominion))
22 2023-12-27 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant's Reply to Respondent's Return
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant\'s Reply to Respondent\'s Return Cover Letter with Note about filing fee Proof of Service Email from Counsel Filing Fee Receipt
23 2023-12-28 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
24 2023-12-29 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant's Reply to Respondent's Return)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant\'s Reply to Respondent\'s Return)
25 2024-01-02 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) Appellant's Reply to Respondent's Return
Appellant\'s Reply to Respondent\'s Return with note about filing fee Email from Counsel
26 2024-01-02 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
27 2024-01-04 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) Appellant's Reply to Respondent's Return)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) Appellant\'s Reply to Respondent\'s Return)
28 2024-01-09 Motion - Reply to Respondent's Return to Emergency Petition for Writ of Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing
Motion - Reply to Respondent\'s Return to Emergency Petition for Writ of Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing (Exhibits) Proof of Service Email from Counsel Email from Counsel 2 Cover Letter
29 2024-01-09 Appellant's Motion - to Amend Reply and Attach Corrected Exhibit
Appellant\'s Motion - to Amend Reply and Attach Corrected Exhibit Cover Letter with Note about filing fee
30 2024-01-10 Respondent's (Dominion Energy) Motion - Surreply to Appellant's Emergency Petition for Writ of Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing
Respondent\'s (Dominion Energy) Motion - Surreply to Appellant\'s Emergency Petition for Writ of Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing with note Email from Counsel
31 2024-01-10 Respondent's (Dominion Energy) Motion - for Leave to File Surreply
Respondent\'s (Dominion Energy) Motion - for Leave to File Surreply
32 2024-01-10 Respondent's (Dominion Energy) Motion - to Amend Return to Correct Typographical Error
Respondent\'s (Dominion Energy) Motion - to Amend Return to Correct Typographical Error Corrected Return Email from Counsel
33 2024-01-10 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Expedited Hearing of the Emergency Petition, Denying Dominion's Request to Dismiss, and to Remand the Petition for Writ of Supersedeas to Administrative Law Court - To Provide Status Update
Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Expedited Hearing of the Emergency Petition, Denying Dominion\'s Request to Dismiss, and to Remand the Peti Email to Counsel
34 2024-01-11 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Reply to Respondent's Return to Emergency Petition for Writ of Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited Hearing)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Reply to Respondent\'s Return to Emergency Petition for Writ of Supersedeas and Motion for Expedited
35 2024-01-12 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fees for Respondent's (Dominion Energy) Motion - to Amend Return to Correct Typographical Error and Respondent's (Dominion Energy) Motion - for Leave to File Surreply)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fees for Respondent\'s (Dominion Energy) Motion - to Amend Return to Correct Typographical Error and Respondent\'s (Do
36 2024-02-23 Correspondence - Incoming (Notification of Going Before the Administrative Law Court)
Correspondence - Incoming (Notification of Going Before the Administrative Law Court)
37 2024-03-13 Correspondence - Incoming (Status Update) (Notice of Hearing Before Administrative Law Court)
Correspondence - Incoming (Status Update) (Notice of Hearing Before Administrative Law Court)
38 2024-04-03 Motion - Request for Leave to Re-File Petition
Motion - Request for Leave to Re-File Petition Email from Counsel
39 2024-04-03 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Request for Leave to Re-File Petition
Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Request for Leave to Re-File Petition Email to Counsel
40 2024-04-09 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Request for Leave to Re-File Petition)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Request for Leave to Re-File Petition)
41 2024-04-15 Motion - Petition for Writ of Supersedeas
Motion - Petition for Writ of Supersedeas Exhibits
42 2024-04-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Petition for Writ of Supersedeas)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Petition for Writ of Supersedeas)
43 2024-04-25 Motion - Return (Petition for Writ of Supersedeas)
Return Proof of Service Cover Letter Exhibit A Exhibit B
44 2024-04-25 Motion - Return (Petition for Writ of Supersedeas)
Return Return
45 2024-04-30 Motion - Reply
Motion - Reply Email from Counsel
46 2024-05-13 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order
Order
47 2024-05-16 Correspondence - Outgoing (To Provide Initial Brief)
Correspondence - Outgoing (To Provide Initial Brief) Email to Counsel
48 2024-06-12 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant's Initial Brief
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant\'s Initial Brief Email from Counsel with note about filing fee
49 2024-06-12 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
50 2024-06-17 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant's Initial Brief)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Appellant\'s Initial Brief)
51 2024-07-15 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) Appellant's Initial Brief
Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) Appellant\'s Initial Brief Email from Counsel
52 2024-07-16 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
53 2024-07-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) Appellant's Initial Brief)
Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee for Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) Appellant\'s Initial Brief)
54 2024-08-01 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed Proof of Service
55 2024-08-02 Initial Brief - Appellant
Initial Brief - Appellant Proof of Service Email from Counsel
56 2024-08-05 Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's Filing Fee)
Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s Filing Fee)
57 2024-08-20 Motion - Substitute The South Carolina Department of Environmental Services as Respondent
Motion - Substitute The South Carolina Department of Environmental Services as Respondent Email from Counsel
58 2024-09-03 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondents' Joint Initial Briefs
Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondents\' Joint Initial Briefs Email from Counsel
59 2024-09-03 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted Email to Counsel
60 2024-09-12 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Substitute The South Carolina Department of Environmental Services as Respondent
Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion - Substitute The South Carolina Department of Environmental Services as Respondent Email to Counsel
61 2024-09-12 Correspondence - Outgoing (Correct Case Title)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Correct Case Title) Email to Counsel
62 2024-09-19 Initial Brief - Respondent (Dominion Energy)
Initial Brief - Respondent (Dominion Energy) Proof of Service Email from Counsel
63 2024-09-19 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
64 2024-09-19 Initial Brief - Respondent (SCDES)
Initial Brief - Respondent (SCDES) Proof of Service Email from Counsel
65 2024-09-19 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
66 2024-09-20 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Appellant's Initial Reply Brief)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Counsel Motion Fee
67 2024-09-26 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Appellant's Initial Reply Brief)
Extension Granted Email to Counsel
68 2024-10-21 Initial Brief - Reply
Initial Brief - Reply Proof of Service Email from Counsel
69 2024-10-21 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed Proof of Service Email from Counsel
70 2024-11-01 Correspondence - Outgoing (Bound Copy Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Bound Copy Letter) Email to Counsel
71 2024-11-20 Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
72 2024-12-10 Record - Record on Appeal Filed (10 copies)
Record on Appeal Vol 1 Record on Appeal Vol 2 Record on Appeal Vol 3 Record on Appeal Vol 4
73 2024-12-10 Final Brief - Appellant (10 copies)
Final Brief - Appellant Proof of Service
74 2024-12-10 Final Brief - Reply (10 copies)
Final Brief - Reply Proof of Service
75 2024-12-10 Final Brief - Respondent (Dominion Energy)(10 copies)
Final Brief - Respondent (Dominion Energy) Email from Counsel
76 2024-12-10 Final Brief - Respondent (SCDES)(10 copies)
Final Brief - Respondent (SCDES) Proof of Service Email from Counsel
77 2025-03-06 Correspondence - Outgoing (6 Bound Copy Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (6 Bound Copy Letter) Email to Counsel
78 2025-03-10 Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant's 6 Bound Copies)
Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant\'s 6 Bound Copies) Email from Counsel
79 2025-03-11 Correspondence - Incoming (Supreme Court Order to Certify the Appeal)
Correspondence - Incoming (Supreme Court Order to Certify the Appeal)
80 2025-03-12 Transfer - To Supreme Court
—
81 2025-03-14 Correspondence - Incoming (letter- copies incoming)
Letter Cover Email
82 2025-03-19 Correspondence - Incoming (letter- copies incoming)(Received)
Letter Cover Email
83 2025-03-28 Correspondence - Notice of Appearance Karen C. Ratigan and Benneth W. Smith for Respondent
Notice of Appearance Proof of Service Cover Email
84 2025-04-15 Motion - To Clarify That No Stay Remains in Effect Or, Alternatively, Motion to Vacate
Motion Attachments Cover Letter Cover Email
85 2025-04-25 Motion - Return to Motion To Clarify That No Stay Remains in Effect Or, Alternatively, Motion to Vacate
Return to Motion Proof of Service Cover Letter Cover Email Exhibit A
86 2025-05-02 Motion - Reply to Return to Motion To Clarify
Reply to Return to Motion Proof of Service Cover Letter Cover Email
87 2025-05-12 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae
Amicus Motion Proof of Service Cover Email
88 2025-05-12 Brief - Amicus (American Rivers, et al)(10 copies)
Amici Brief (American Rivers, et al) Proof of Service
89 2025-05-14 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Amicus for American Rivers
Order
90 2025-05-16 Correspondence - Incoming (Copies en route)(Arrived)
Letter Cover Email
91 2025-06-11 Brief - Amicus Reply (Dominion)(10 copies)
Amicus Response Brief (Dominion) Proof of Service Cover Email Cover Letter
92 2025-06-11 Brief - Amicus Reply (Blue Ridge)(10 copies)
Amicus Response Brief (Blue Ridge) Proof of Service Cover Letter Cover Email
93 2025-06-13 Correspondence - Incoming (ELIZABETH PARTLOW arguing for Dominion)
Letter Cover Email
94 2025-06-13 Correspondence - Incoming (JESSE SANCHEZ AND STEPHEN SPITZ arguing for Appellant)
Email
95 2025-06-13 Correspondence - Incoming (BENNETT SMITH arguing for SCDES)
Email
96 2025-06-24 Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
ETV Video
97 2026-01-13 Correspondence - Incoming (Status Request from Counsel)
Status Request Cover Email
98 2026-01-16 Correspondence - Outgoing (Other)
Letter
99 2026-01-28 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Op. 28315 Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League v. SCDES.pdf
100 2026-02-13 Rehearing - No Petition for Rehearing Filed - Remittitur to be Sent
—
101 2026-02-13 Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
Remittitur
102 2026-02-17 Motion - Costs
Motion - Costs Itemized Statement Proof of Service Cover Letter Cover Email
103 2026-03-04 Motion - No Return
—
104 2026-04-21 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Costs
Order