← Index Overview
Court of Appeals

2022-001312 (cons)

Court of Appeals
C-Track →
Decision Filed

Heidi Gersten v. Kevin Carter (2)

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal Chester (2018CP1200117, 2018CP1200074)
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2022-09-19
Case Type Common Pleas Case Subtype Other
Filed Date 2022-09-19 Argument Date —
Disposition Date 2024-09-24 Remittitur Date —
Last Action Event 2025-05-02
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2022-09-19 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial
notice of appeal order dated 4/28/2018 order dated 5/22/2018 order dated 9/19/2018 order dated 9/19/2018 (2) order dated 9/21/2018 order dated 9/21/2018 (2) order dated 9/24/2018 order dated 3/7/2022 email copy of emailed noa
2 2022-09-22 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
notice of appeal initial letter email to counsel
3 2022-10-05 Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (P. Dworjanyn, Esq. and M. Burchstead, Esq.)
motion correspondence (email) Filing Fee
4 2022-10-14 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - S. Montague, Esq. and J. Laffitte, Esq.)
notice of appearance email
5 2022-10-17 Motion - No Return to Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (P. Dworjanyn, Esq. and M. Burchstead, Esq.)
—
6 2022-10-21 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
transcript ordered email
7 2022-10-21 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (P. Dworjanyn, Esq. and M. Burchstead, Esq.)
order email to counsel
8 2022-10-31 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered (Duplicate - Appellant)
transcript ordered email
9 2022-11-01 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered (Respondents Carter and Davis)
transcript ordered email
10 2022-11-08 Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (K. Brudvig, Esq. and C. Stegmaier, Esq.)
motion email motion fee
11 2022-11-09 Correspondence - Outgoing (Cases Consolidated letter)
letter email to counsel
12 2022-11-09 Motion - Dismiss a Party (Respondent Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club)
motion email motion (via mail)
13 2022-11-16 Motion - Substitute as Counsel (P. Larson, Esq. for D. Sligh, Esq. - Nationwide)
notice of appearance email motion fee
14 2022-11-21 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Return to Motion to Dismiss a Party -Respondent Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club)
motion for extension email motion fee
15 2022-11-22 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Return to Motion to Dismiss a Party -Respondent Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club)
order email to counsel
16 2022-11-28 Motion - No Return to Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (K. Brudvig, Esq. and C. Stegmaier, Esq.)
—
17 2022-11-28 Motion - No Return to Motion - Substitute as Counsel (P. Larson, Esq. for D. Sligh, Esq. - Nationwide)
—
18 2022-12-01 Motion - Appellant's Return to Motion - Dismiss a Party (Respondent Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club)
return to motion ADA Request cover letter email
19 2022-12-06 Motion - No Reply to Appellant's Return to Motion - Dismiss a Party (Respondent Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club)
—
20 2022-12-07 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motions - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel)
order email to counsel
21 2022-12-13 Correspondence - Incoming (Amended Notice of Appearance - S. Montague, Esq. and J. Laffitte, Esq.)
amended notice of appearance email
22 2022-12-28 Motion - Substitute as Counsel (P. Larson, Esq. for D. Sligh, Esq. - Nationwide and J. Tirbovich)(Amended)
amended motion email email 2
23 2022-12-28 Motion - Dismiss a Party (Nationwide Insurance Company and Joseph Tirbovich)
motion dismiss party email
24 2023-01-06 Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal
transcript delivered email transcript delivered (via mail)
25 2023-01-09 Motion - Strike or in the contra Motion for Extension of Time to File Return to Nationwide Insurance Company and Joseph Tirbovich's Motion to Dismiss Party and Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act Reasonable Accommodations Request
motion motion fee
26 2023-01-09 Motion - No Return to Motion - Substitute as Counsel (P. Larson, Esq. for D. Sligh, Esq. - Nationwide and J. Tirbovich)(Amended)
—
27 2023-01-11 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Substitute as Counsel (P. Larson, Esq. for D. Sligh, Esq. - Nationwide and J. Tirbovich)(Amended) and (Motion for Extension)
order email to counsel
28 2023-01-12 Motion - Dismiss (Respondents Carter and Davis)
motion to dismiss
29 2023-01-13 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Motion - Dismiss (Respondents Carter and Davis))
deficiency letter email to counsel
30 2023-01-17 Deficiency - Correction (Motion - Dismiss (Respondents Carter and Davis))
motion fee
31 2023-01-18 Dispositional Decision - Order
order email to counsel
32 2023-02-02 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Motion to Reinstate)
motion for extension email
33 2023-02-06 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st)(Motion to Reinstate)
order email to counsel motion fee
34 2023-02-13 Motion - Emergency 2nd Request Title II of ADA to Permit Appellant to Serve Respondents via Email
motion email
35 2023-02-15 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion for Emergency 2nd Request Title II of ADA to Permit Appellant to Serve Respondents via Email) 2022-001312
Order Email to Counsel and Appellant
36 2023-02-15 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion for Emergency 2nd Request Title II of ADA to Permit Appellant to Serve Respondents via Email) 2022-001390
Order Email to Counsel and Appellant
37 2023-02-17 Motion - Reinstate
motion to reinstate email
38 2023-03-02 Motion - Return (Respondents Nationwide Insurance Company and Joseph Tirbovich)
return to motion email
39 2023-03-07 Motion - No Reply (Return to Motion - Reinstate)
—
40 2023-03-30 Non-Dispositional Decision - Reinstatement of Appeal or Matter
order cover letter email to counsel
41 2023-04-18 Correspondence - Outgoing (Transcript Status)
letter email to counsel
42 2023-05-05 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Title II of ADA to Accept Status Update and Motion for Extension to File Brief and Amended Rules 221 and 260 Petition for Rehearing, Reinstatement, and Reply to Return to Petition for Reinstatement as Timely Filed)
motion email
43 2023-05-24 Motion - No Return to Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Title II of ADA to Accept Status Update and Motion for Extension to File Brief and Amended Rules 221 and 260 Petition for Rehearing, Reinstatement, and Reply to Return to Petition for Reinstatement as Timely Filed)
—
44 2023-05-31 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
order email to counsel
45 2023-06-30 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)(Appellant's Initial Brief)
motion for extension email
46 2023-07-03 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (2nd)(Appellant's Initial Brief)
order email to counsel
47 2023-07-31 Initial Brief - Appellant
appellant\'s initial brief cover letter email
48 2023-07-31 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Appellant)
designation of matter cover letter email
49 2023-07-31 Motion - To File Rule 60(b), SCRCP Motion and Motion to Lift Automatic Stay, Remand, and Stay Appeal
motion cover letter email motion fee
50 2023-08-01 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Initial Brief - Appellant)
deficiency letter email to counsel
51 2023-08-08 Motion - Return to Motion - To File Rule 60(b), SCRCP Motion and Motion to Lift Automatic Stay, Remand, and Stay Appeal
return to motion email
52 2023-08-15 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Reply to Return)
motion for extension email
53 2023-08-16 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Reply to Return)
order email to counsel
54 2023-08-25 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)(Reply to Return)
motion for extension email
55 2023-08-28 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (2nd)(Reply to Return)
order email to counsel
56 2023-08-29 Initial Brief - Respondent
respondent\'s initial brief proof of service email
57 2023-08-29 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Designation of Matter)
designation of matter proof of service email
58 2023-09-05 Motion - Reply to Return to Motion - To File Rule 60(b), SCRCP Motion and Motion to Lift Automatic Stay, Remand, and Stay Appeal
reply to return cover letter email
59 2023-09-05 Motion - To File Rule 60(b), SCRCP Motion and Motion to Lift Automatic Stay, Remand, and Stay Appeal (AMENDED)
amended motion cover letter email
60 2023-09-08 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Appellant's Reply Brief)
motion for extension email
61 2023-09-18 Motion - No Return to Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Appellant's Reply Brief)
—
62 2023-09-21 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st)(Appellant's Reply Brief)
order email to counsel
63 2023-10-10 Initial Brief - Reply
appellant\'s initial reply brief email
64 2023-10-12 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Initial Brief - Reply)
deficiency letter email to counsel
65 2023-10-23 Motion - Allow Late Filing of Reply Brief
motion cover letter email
66 2023-10-23 Initial Brief - Reply (Amended)
amended reply brief cover letter email
67 2023-10-24 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Reply (Amended))
deficiency letter email to counsel
68 2023-10-30 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion - To File Rule 60(b), SCRCP Motion and Motion to Lift Automatic Stay, Remand, and Stay Appeal)
order email to counsel
69 2023-11-21 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion - Allow Late Filing of Reply Brief)
order
70 2023-11-21 Correspondence - Outgoing (One Bound Copy Letter)
one bound copy letter
71 2023-12-21 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Record on Appeal and Final Briefs)
record on appeal cover letter email
72 2023-12-27 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st)(Record on Appeal and Final Briefs)
order
73 2024-01-03 Motion - Substitute as Counsel
motion email
74 2024-01-08 Non-Dispositional Decision - Withdrawn or Ended (Motion - Substitute as Counsel)
letter
75 2024-01-22 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Record on Appeal)
motion for extension email
76 2024-01-23 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted(1st)(Record on Appeal)
order
77 2024-02-21 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (Record on Appeal and Final Briefs)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
78 2024-02-22 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Record on Appeal and Final Briefs)
Extension Granted Email to Counsel
79 2024-03-22 Correspondence - Incoming (Cover and Index of Record on Appeal)
Correspondence Proof of Service Email from Appellant
80 2024-04-05 Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent's Response to Record)
Correspondence Email from Counsel
81 2024-04-09 Correspondence - Outgoing (Complete Record on Appeal Due)
Complete Record on Appeal Due Letter Email to Counsel
82 2024-04-19 Record - Record on Appeal Filed
Record on Appeal Proof of Service E-Mail
83 2024-04-19 Motion - Allow Late Filing
Motion - Allow Late Filing Cover Letter Proof of Service
84 2024-04-23 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Concerning Designated Items)
Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Concerning Designated Items) E-Mail
85 2024-05-29 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Filing Fee and Record on Appeal)
Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Filing Fee and Record on Appeal)
86 2024-05-29 Correspondence - Outgoing (Response to Counsel's Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing (Response to Counsel\'s Letter)
87 2024-06-10 Deficiency - Correction (Record on Appeal)
Amended Record on Appeal Email from Appellant
88 2024-06-10 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Record on Appeal and Appellant's Final Brief)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant Email from Appellant 2
89 2024-06-10 Motion - Amended Extension of Time (1st) (Record on Appeal and Appellant's Final Brief)
Amended Motion for Extension of Time Receipt
90 2024-06-12 Motion - Dismiss
Motion to Dismiss Motion Fee
91 2024-06-25 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Return to Motion to Dismiss)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
92 2024-06-26 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Return to Motion to Dismiss)
Extension Granted Email to Counsel and Appellant
93 2024-07-05 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (Record on Appeal and Appellant's Final Brief)
Motion for Extension Email to Counsel
94 2024-07-15 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (Return to Motion to Dismiss)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
95 2024-07-17 Non-Dispositional Decision - Withdrawn or Ended (Motion for Extension - Record on Appeal and Appellant's Final Brief)
Letter Email to Counsel
96 2024-07-17 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Return to Motion to Dismiss)
Extension Granted Email to Counsel
97 2024-07-25 Motion - Return (Motion to Dismiss)
Return Email from Appellant
98 2024-08-01 Motion - Amended Return (Motion to Dismiss)
Amended Return Email from Appellant
99 2024-08-12 Motion - Return (Second Return to Motion to Dismiss)
Motion - Return (Second Return to Motion to Dismiss) Part 2 to Return Part 3 to Return Part 4 to Return Cover Letter E-Mail
100 2024-08-12 Motion - Reply (to Return to Motion to Dismiss)
Motion - Reply (to Return to Motion to Dismiss) Proof of Service
101 2024-08-19 Motion - Reply to Appellant's Unauthorized Second Return
Motion - Reply to Appellant\'s Unauthorized Second Return E-Mail
102 2024-09-24 Dispositional Decision - Order
Order Email to Counsel and Appellant
103 2024-10-08 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Petition for Rehearing)
Motion for Extension of Time
104 2024-10-09 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Petition for Rehearing)
Extension Granted Email to Counsel and Appellant
105 2024-10-24 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (Petition for Rehearing)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
106 2024-10-24 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Petition for Rehearing)
Extension Granted Email to Counsel
107 2024-11-08 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing
Petition for Rehearing Email from Appellant
108 2024-11-15 Rehearing - Return
Return Email from Counsel
109 2024-11-22 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Reply to Return)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
110 2024-11-25 Motion - Motion to Amend
Motion Cover Letter Email from Appellant
111 2024-11-25 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Amended)
Amended Motion Cover Letter Email from Appellant
112 2024-12-03 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (Reply to Return)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
113 2024-12-04 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Extension Granted Email to Counsel
114 2024-12-06 Motion - Extension of Time (3rd) (Reply to Return)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
115 2024-12-09 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Reply to Return)
Extension Granted Extension Granted
116 2024-12-10 Motion - Extension of Time (4th) (Reply to Return)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
117 2024-12-11 Correspondence - Incoming (Amended Proof of Service)
Amended Proof of Service Email from Appellant
118 2024-12-16 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (4th) (Reply to Return)
Order Email to Counsel
119 2024-12-18 Rehearing - Reply
Reply Email from Appellant
120 2025-02-10 Rehearing - Denied
Order Email to Counsel and Appellant
121 2025-03-12 Correspondence - Incoming (Motion for Extension)
Motion for Extension Email from Appellant
122 2025-03-14 Correspondence - Incoming (Supreme Court Extension Order)
Supreme Court Order
123 2025-04-01 Correspondence - Incoming (Motion for Extension)
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Appellant
124 2025-04-03 Correspondence - Incoming (Supreme Court Extension Granted)
Supreme Court Order
125 2025-05-01 Correspondence - Incoming (Petition for Writ of Certiorari)
Petition for Writ of Certiorari Email from Appellant
126 2025-05-02 Correspondence - Incoming (Supreme Court Letter)
Supreme Court Letter