← Index Overview
Court of Appeals

2021-001050

Court of Appeals
C-Track →
Ended

Builders FirstSource-Southeast Group, LLC v. Palmetto Trim and Renovation

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal Charleston (2016CP1003783)
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2021-09-22
Case Type Common Pleas Case Subtype Other
Filed Date 2021-09-22 Argument Date 2024-03-05
Disposition Date 2025-05-21 Remittitur Date —
Last Action Event 2026-05-15
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2021-09-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Palmetto Trim and Renovation)
Notice of Appeal Order (July 26, 2021) Order (August 23, 2021) Email Original and Filing Fee Original Order (July 26) Original Order (August 23)
2 2021-09-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (Hurley Services, LLC)
Notice of Appeal Order (July 07, 2021) Order (August 23, 2021) Email Original Notice of Appeal and Filing Fee Original Order (July 07) Original Order (August 23)
3 2021-09-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (ECC Contracting, LLC)
Notice of Appeal Order (July 07, 2021) Order (August 23, 2021) Email Original Notice of Appeal and Filing Fee Original Order (July 07) Original Order (August 23)
4 2021-09-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (East Coast Carpentry)
Notice of Appeal Order (July 29, 2021) Order (August 23, 2021) Email Original Notice of Appeal and Filing Fee Original Order (July 29) Order (August 23)
5 2021-09-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (AC Construction, Inc.)
Notice of Appeal Order (July 07, 2021) Order (August 23, 2021) Email Original Notice of Appeal and Filing Fee Original Order (July 07) Original Order (August 23)
6 2021-09-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (WS Contractors, LLC)
Notice of Appeal Order (July 29, 2021) Email Original Notice of Appeal and Filing Fee Order (July 29) Order (August 23, 2021)
7 2021-09-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (Pohlman Quality Exteriors, Inc.)
Notice of Appeal Order (July 07, 2021) Email Original Notice of Appeal and Filing Fee Order (July 07) Order (August 23, 2021)
8 2021-09-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second or Subsequent (L&G Construction Group, LLC)
Notice of Appeal Order (July 07, 2021) Email Original Notice of Appeal and Filing Fee Original Order (July 07) Original Order (August 23)
9 2021-10-07 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal - Initial Letter)
Initial Letter Email
10 2021-10-25 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Objecting Consolidation)
Letter
11 2021-11-10 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter from Opposing Counsel to Reject Appellant's Request)
Letter Email
12 2021-11-10 Correspondence - Incoming (Email from E. Glenn Elliott)
Email
13 2021-11-22 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Regarding Consolidation Correspondence)
Motion Email
14 2021-12-02 Motion - Return (Regarding Consolidation)
Return to Motion Email
15 2022-01-28 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted, Motion for Status Conference Denied
Extension Granted Email
16 2022-02-28 Initial Brief - Appellant
Initial Brief of Appellant Email
17 2022-02-28 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter Email
18 2022-03-09 Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (John Linton Substituting for Ian Freeman for WS Contractors, LLC)
Motion to Substitute Counsel
19 2022-03-09 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Regarding Counsel)
Letter
20 2022-03-17 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - J. Barnwell Fishburne for Respondent AC Construction, Inc.)
Notice of Appearance Email Motion Fee
21 2022-03-18 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (AC Construction, Inc.)
Motion for Extension
22 2022-03-18 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter Regarding Counsel)
Letter Email
23 2022-03-21 Initial Brief - Respondent (Hurley Services, LLC)
Initial Brief of Respondent Email
24 2022-03-21 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter Email
25 2022-03-22 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (WS Contractors, LLC)
Motion for Extension Email Email (Acknowledging Wrong Filing Fee) Amended Cover Letter Email (2) Motion Fee
26 2022-03-22 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Palmetto Trim and Renovation)
Motion for Extension Email Motion Fee
27 2022-03-24 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Extension Granted Email
28 2022-03-25 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (ECC Contracting, LLC)
Motion for Extension Email Motion Fee
29 2022-03-25 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (John Linton Substitutes as Counsel for Ian Freeman)
Order Email
30 2022-03-28 Initial Brief - Respondent (Pohlman Quality Exteriors, Inc.)
Initial Brief of Respondent Email
31 2022-03-28 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Pohlman Quality Exteriors, Inc.)
Designation of Matter Email
32 2022-03-29 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (ECC Contracting, LLC)
Extension Granted Email
33 2022-03-30 Correspondence - Incoming (L&G Construction Group, LLC wishes to join the initial brief of Hurley Services, LLC)
Letter Email
34 2022-03-31 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Regarding Deadlines)
Letter
35 2022-04-04 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (East Coast Contracting)
Motion for Extension Email Motion Fee
36 2022-04-04 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter Regarding Timelines)
Letter Email
37 2022-04-06 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Extension Granted Email
38 2022-04-07 Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (Mary Bass Lohr Withdraws for Builders FirstSource - Southeast Group, LLC)
Motion to Withdraw as Counsel Email
39 2022-04-07 Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel (Catherine L. Floeder Withdraws for Builders FirstSource - Southeast Group, LLC)
Motion to Withdraw as Counsel Email
40 2022-04-27 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (WS Contractors, LLC)
Motion for Extension Email Motion Fee
41 2022-04-27 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (WS Contractors, LLC)
Extension Granted Email
42 2022-04-27 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Catherine Floeder and Mary Bass Lohr Withdraw as Counsel)
Order Email
43 2022-04-29 Initial Brief - Respondent (Palmetto Trim and Renovation)
Initial Brief of Respondent Email
44 2022-04-29 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Palmetto Trim and Renovation)
Designation of Matter Email
45 2022-04-29 Initial Brief - Respondent (AC Construction, Inc.)
Initial Brief of Respondent Email
46 2022-04-29 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (AC Construction, Inc.)
Designation of Matter Email
47 2022-05-16 Initial Brief - Respondent (East Coast Carpentry)
Initial Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Email
48 2022-05-16 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (East Coast Carpentry)
Designation of Matter Proof of Service Email
49 2022-05-16 Initial Brief - Respondent (ECC Contracting, LLC)
Initial Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Email
50 2022-05-17 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (ECC Contracting, LLC)
Designation of Matter Proof of Service Email
51 2022-05-31 Initial Brief - Respondent (WS Contractors, LLC)
Initial Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Email Email (2)
52 2022-05-31 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (WS Contractors, LLC)
Designation of Matter Proof of Service Email Email (2)
53 2022-06-08 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Initial Reply Brief)
Motion for Extension Email
54 2022-06-09 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Extension Granted
55 2022-07-14 Motion - Exceed Page Limit
Motion to Exceed Page Limits Email
56 2022-07-22 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
Motion for Extension Letter Email
57 2022-07-26 Non-Dispositional Decision - Withdrawn or Ended (Motion for Extension Not Ruled On, HIA)
Letter Email
58 2022-09-12 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order
Order Email
59 2022-09-22 Initial Brief - Reply
Initial Reply Brief of Appellant Email
60 2022-09-23 Correspondence - Outgoing (Bound Copies)
Bound Copies Letter Email
61 2022-10-24 Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
Proof of Service Letter
62 2022-10-24 Record - Record on Appeal Filed
Record on Appeal (Volume 1) Record on Appeal (Volume 2) Record on Appeal (Volume 3) Record on Appeal (Volume 4) Record on Appeal (Volume 5) Record on Appeal (Volume 6)
63 2022-10-26 Final Brief - Respondent (Hurley Services, LLC)
Final Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Letter Email
64 2022-11-14 Final Brief - Respondent (ECC Contracting, LLC)
Final Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Letter Email Original
65 2022-11-14 Final Brief - Appellant
Final Brief of Appellant Letter Proof of Service
66 2022-11-14 Final Brief - Reply
Final Reply Brief of Appellant Email
67 2022-11-14 Final Brief - Respondent (AC Construction, LLC)
Final Brief of Respondent Proof of Service
68 2022-11-14 Final Brief - Respondent (Palmetto Trim and Renovation)
Final Brief of Respondent Letter Email
69 2022-11-14 Final Brief - Respondent (East Coast Carpentry)
Final Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Email Original
70 2022-11-14 Final Brief - Respondent (Pohlman Quality Exteriors, Inc.)
Final Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Email
71 2022-11-14 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (WS Contractors, LLC)
Motion for Extension Email Motion Fee
72 2022-11-14 Supplemental Citations - Received
Supplemental Citations Email
73 2022-11-16 Supplemental Citations - Received
Supplemental Citation Email
74 2022-11-18 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Extension Granted Email
75 2022-11-21 Supplemental Citations - Received
Supplemental Citation Email
76 2022-12-02 Final Brief - Respondent (WS Contractors, LLC)
Final Brief of Respondent
77 2022-12-02 Record - Supplemental
Supplemental Record on Appeal Email
78 2022-12-05 Motion - Supplement Record (Consent)
Motion Motion Fee
79 2022-12-05 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion to Supplement ROA Granted)
Order Email
80 2023-03-13 Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel
Motion Email Motion Fee
81 2023-03-14 Correspondence - Outgoing (6 Bound Copies Letter)
Letter Email
82 2023-03-16 Correspondence - Incoming (6 Bound Copies of Hurley Services, LLC RFB)
Letter Email
83 2023-03-17 Correspondence - Incoming (6 Bound Copies: Pohlman Quality Exteriors, Inc.)
Letter Email
84 2023-03-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Todd Flippin)
Notice of Appearance Email
85 2023-03-21 Correspondence - Incoming (6 Bound Copies AFB, AFRB, ROA)
Letter Email
86 2023-03-22 Correspondence - Incoming (6 Bound Copies of ECC Contracting RFB)
Letter Email
87 2023-03-27 Correspondence - Incoming (6 Bound Copies RFB WS Contractors, LLC)
Letter Email
88 2023-04-04 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Finley Clarke Relieved)
Order Email
89 2023-08-15 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
Conflict Letter
90 2023-08-25 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Flippin - no conflicts
91 2023-08-28 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Hughes - no conflicts Ivey - no conflicts
92 2023-10-11 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
Conflict Letter
93 2023-10-12 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Ivey - no conflicts Elliot - no conflicts Fishburne - not 2/15
94 2023-10-19 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Flippin - no conflicts
95 2023-10-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Best - no conflicts
96 2023-10-23 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Cox - no conflicts
97 2023-11-07 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
Letter Email
98 2023-11-13 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Hughes - no conflicts Flippin - no conflicts
99 2023-11-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Fishburne - no conflicts
100 2024-02-01 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Oral Argument)
Notice of Oral Argument Email to Counsel
101 2024-03-05 Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
—
102 2025-02-12 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Cover Letter
103 2025-02-27 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing
Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing E-Mail Motion Fee
104 2025-05-21 Rehearing - Denied with Substitute Opinion
Rehearing - Denied with Substitute Opinion E-Mail
105 2025-05-21 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Dispositional Decision - Opinion
106 2025-06-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for Writ of Cert)
Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for Writ of Cert) E-Mail
107 2025-06-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Supreme Court Initial Letter)
Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Supreme Court Initial Letter)
108 2025-06-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Email to Supreme Court)
Correspondence - Incoming (Email to Supreme Court)
109 2025-07-16 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
110 2025-07-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
111 2025-07-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Letter to Supreme Court)
Letter 1 Letter 2 Letter 3 Email Email 2 Email 3
112 2025-07-21 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
113 2025-07-31 Correspondence - Incoming (Returns to Petition for Cert)
Return to Cert 1 Return to Cert 2 Return to Cert 3 Return to Cert 4 Email Email 2
114 2025-08-07 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
115 2025-08-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Reply)
Correspondence - Incoming (Reply) Email
116 2025-09-08 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
117 2025-09-08 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
118 2025-10-08 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
119 2025-10-13 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
120 2025-12-16 Correspondence - Incoming (Supreme Court Order Granting Certiorari)
Correspondence - Incoming (Supreme Court Order Granting Certiorari)
121 2025-12-17 Ended - Matter Concluded
—
122 2026-01-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion)
Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion) Proof of Service Email
123 2026-01-27 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Supreme Court Filings)
Petitioner\'s Brief Email Appendix
124 2026-03-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Returns)
Return from Hurley Services Return from Pohlman Quality Email Email 2
125 2026-03-25 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
126 2026-04-29 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Reply Reply 2 Reply 3 Reply 4 Reply 5 Motion Cover Letter Email
127 2026-05-12 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email
128 2026-05-15 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Correspondence - Incoming (Other) Email