← Index Overview
Court of Appeals

2021-000272

Court of Appeals
C-Track →
Remittitur

TCC of Charleston, Inc. v. Concord and Cumberland, LLC

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal Charleston (2016CP1002955)
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2021-03-11
Case Type Common Pleas Case Subtype Other
Filed Date 2021-03-11 Argument Date 2024-06-11
Disposition Date 2025-07-30 Remittitur Date 2026-01-20
Last Action Event 2026-01-20
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2021-03-11 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial
notice of appeal order (02/16/2021 - exhibit A) order (02/16/2021 - exhibit B) order (03/03/2021) email cover letter filing fee
2 2021-03-16 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Cross Appeal
notice of appeal - cross appeal order (01/30/2020) order (05/01/2020) order (02/16/2021) email cover letter filing fee
3 2021-03-17 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered (Appellant/Respondent)
letter ordering transcript
4 2021-03-17 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered (Respondent/Appellant)
letter ordering transcript
5 2021-03-17 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
notice of appeal initial letter email to counsel
6 2021-03-17 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial)
deficiency letter email to counsel
7 2021-03-18 Deficiency - Correction (Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial)
correction - filing fee
8 2021-03-22 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Multiple Notices Received Letter)
multiple notices received letter email to counsel
9 2021-03-26 Correspondence - Incoming (Appellant/Respondent's Correspondence)
letter email cover letter
10 2021-03-31 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second (Appellant/Respondent)
notice of appeal proof of service order (03/26/2021) cover letter letter to lower court filing fee
11 2021-04-02 Transcript Documents - No Transcript to be Ordered
letter
12 2021-04-06 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Multiple Notices Received Letter)
letter email to counsel
13 2021-04-09 Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal (Appellant/Respondent)
letter of transcript delivery
14 2021-04-20 Correspondence - Outgoing (Response to Email from Respondent/Appellant's Counsel Requesting Confirmation of Initial Briefing Timeline)
letter email to counsel
15 2021-04-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Email from Respondent/Appellant's Counsel Requesting Confirmation of Initial Briefing Timeline)
email from counsel
16 2021-05-05 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - Russell G. Hines, Esquire)
notice of appearance email cover letter
17 2021-05-11 Appellant's Initial Brief of Appellant/Respondent
appellant\'s initial brief of appellant/respondent proof of service
18 2021-05-11 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Appellant's Initial Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
designation of matter proof of service
19 2021-05-11 Appellant's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant
appellant\'s initial brief of respondent/appellant email cover letter
20 2021-05-11 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Appellant's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant)
designation of matter email cover letter
21 2021-06-09 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Betty L. Beatty's Respondent's Initial Brief)
Motion for Extension of Time
22 2021-06-09 Respondent's Initial Brief of Appellant/Respondent
Respondent\'s Initial Brief Proof of Service Email from Counsel
23 2021-06-09 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter (Appellant/Respondent)
Designation of Matter Email to Counsel Proof of Service
24 2021-06-09 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) Respondent's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant
Motion for Extension of Time Email from Counsel
25 2021-06-11 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Betty L. Beatty's Respondent's Initial Brief)
Extension Granted Email to Counsel
26 2021-06-11 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Respondent's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant)
Extension Granted Email to Counsel
27 2021-06-21 Respondent's Initial Brief of Respondent/Appellant
respondent\'s initial brief email cover letter
28 2021-06-21 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Respondent/Appellant)
designation of matter email cover letter
29 2021-06-21 Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Respondent/Appellant
appellant\'s initial reply brief of respondent/appellant email cover letter
30 2021-06-21 Motion - Extension of Time (1st Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
extension request email cover letter corrected extension request received 6/22/2021 email cover letter 6/22/2021
31 2021-06-23 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
order email to counsel
32 2021-06-29 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Respondents' Initial Brief Overdue Letter)
letter email to counsel
33 2021-07-07 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter Regarding Counsel for Respondents)
letter email cover
34 2021-07-09 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (Betty L. Beatty's Respondent's Initial Brief)
Motion Email
35 2021-07-16 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance - William Cole Shannon, Esquire)
notice of appearance email cover letter
36 2021-07-19 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (2nd) (Betty L. Beatty's Respondent's Initial Brief)
order email to counsel
37 2021-07-19 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter to Disregard June 29, 2021 Letter)
letter email to counsel
38 2021-07-26 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd - Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
extension request
39 2021-07-28 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (2nd - Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
order email to counsel
40 2021-08-09 Initial Brief - Respondent (Betty L. Beatty)
respondent\'s initial brief email cover letter
41 2021-08-09 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Respondent Betty L. Beatty)
designation of matter email cover letter
42 2021-08-13 Motion - Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike
Motion to Strike Proof of Service
43 2021-08-16 Deficiency - Correction (Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike)
Motion Deficiency Correction
44 2021-08-17 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike)
Motion Deficiency Letter Email to Counsel
45 2021-08-17 Correspondence - Incoming (Email from F. Cordes Ford IV)
Email from Counsel
46 2021-08-23 Motion - Appellant/Respondent's Return to Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike
return to motion email cover letter
47 2021-08-26 Appellant's Initial Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent
appellant\'s initial reply brief of appellant/respondent
48 2021-08-26 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Appellant/Respondent)
designation of matter
49 2021-08-30 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Respondent/Appellant's Reply to Return to Motion to Strike)
extension request email cover letter
50 2021-09-01 Designation of Matter - Supplemental (Respondent/Appellant)
supplemental designation of matter email cover letter
51 2021-09-01 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st - Respondent/Appellant's Reply to Return to Motion to Strike)
order email to counsel
52 2021-09-09 Motion - Respondent/Appellant's Reply to Appellant/Respondent's Return to Motion to Strike
Reply to Motion
53 2021-09-10 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Record on Appeal)
Motion
54 2021-09-17 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent - Extension of Time (1st) (Serve Record on Appeal)
Letter Email to Counsel
55 2021-09-20 Deficiency - Correction for Extension of Time (1st) (Serve Record on Appeal)
correction - filing fee email cover letter correction - filing fee (original received 9/21/21)
56 2021-10-04 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st - Record on Appeal)
order email to counsel
57 2021-10-14 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Respondent/Appellant's Motion to Strike)
order email to counsel
58 2021-10-27 Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
proof of service email from counsel
59 2021-11-12 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - To File the Record on Appeal and Final Briefs of Appellant/Respondent)
motion for extension proof of service cover letter filing fee
60 2021-11-17 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st - To File the Record on Appeal and Final Briefs of Appellant/Respondent)
order email to counsel
61 2021-12-09 Record - Proof of Service of Corrected Record on Appeal
Proof of Service Email from Counsel
62 2021-12-15 Record - Record on Appeal Filed
Proof of Service Email from Counsel Certificate of Counsel Record on Appeal (Volume 1) Record on Appeal (Volume 2) Record on Appeal (Volume 3) Record on Appeal (Volume 4) Record on Appeal (Volume 5) Record on Appeal (Volume 6)
63 2021-12-15 Appellant's Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent
Appellant\'s Final Brief Proof of Service Email from Counsel
64 2021-12-15 Appellant's Final Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent
Appellant\'s Final Reply Brief of Appellant/Respondent Proof of Service Email from Counsel
65 2021-12-17 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Unbound Originals Letter)
Letter Email to Counsel
66 2021-12-17 Final Brief - Respondent Betty L. Beatty
Respondent\'s Final Brief Email from Counsel
67 2021-12-20 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Record - Record on Appeal Filed)
Deficiency Letter Email to Counsel
68 2021-12-21 Deficiency - Correction (Record - Record on Appeal Filed)
Correction - Record on Appeal (Volume 1) Correction - Record on Appeal (Volume 2) Correction - Record on Appeal (Volume 3) Correction - Record on Appeal (Volume 4) Correction - Record on Appeal (Volume 5) Correction - Record on Appeal (Volume 6) Email from Counsel
69 2021-12-21 Correspondence - Incoming (Bound Copies of Appellant/Respondent's Briefs and Record on Appeal)
Letter Email from Counsel
70 2021-12-29 Respondent's Final Brief of Respondent/Appellant
Respondent\'s Final Brief of Respondent/Appellant Proof of Service Email from Counsel
71 2021-12-29 Appellant's Final Brief of Respondent/Appellant
Appellant\'s Final Brief of Respondent/Appellant Proof of Service Email from Counsel
72 2021-12-29 Appellant's Final Reply Brief of Respondent/Appellant
Appellant\'s Final Reply Brief of Respondent/Appellant Proof of Service Email from Counsel
73 2022-01-05 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Final Brief - Respondent Betty L. Beatty)
Deficiency Letter Email to Counsel
74 2022-01-05 Deficiency - Correction (Final Brief - Respondent Betty L. Beatty)
Correction - Proof of Service Email from Counsel
75 2022-02-03 Respondent's Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent
Respondent\'s Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent Email from Counsel Certificate of Counsel Proof of Service
76 2022-02-04 Motion - Allow Late Filing of Respondent's Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent
Motion to Allow Late Filing Filing Fee
77 2022-02-22 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion - Allow Late Filing of Respondent's Final Brief of Appellant/Respondent)
Order Email to Counsel
78 2022-08-02 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Six Bound Copies Requested)
Letter Email to Counsel
79 2023-07-13 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
Conflict Letter Email to Counsel
80 2023-08-15 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter)
Conflict Letter Email to Counsel
81 2023-08-29 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Hines
82 2023-10-11 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter for Oral Argument)
Conflict Letter Email to Counsel
83 2023-10-11 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Grimball - not 2/15
84 2023-11-07 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)
Conflict Letter Email to Counsel
85 2023-11-07 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Grimball - no conflicts
86 2023-12-05 Correspondence - Outgoing (Conflict Letter for Oral Argument)
Conflict Letter Email to Counsel
87 2023-12-06 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)
Grimball - no conflicts
88 2024-03-01 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Oral Argument)
Notice of Oral Argument
89 2024-03-07 Correspondence - Outgoing (Oral Argument Times Letter)
Correspondence - Outgoing Email to Counsel
90 2024-03-12 Oral Argument - Removed from Roster
—
91 2024-03-12 Correspondence - Outgoing (canceling oral argument)
Email to Counsel
92 2024-03-27 Correspondence - Outgoing (Rescheduling for June 2024)
Email to Counsel
93 2024-03-27 Correspondence - Incoming (Responses from Counsel)
Ford (not June 3) Rannik (not June 3, pref June 11)
94 2024-04-30 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Oral Argument)
Letter - Notice of Oral Argument Email to Counsel
95 2024-06-11 Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
—
96 2025-03-19 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Cover Letter Email to Counsel
97 2025-04-03 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(for respondent Betty Beatty's PFR)
Motion Email
98 2025-04-03 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing(Respondent-Appellant)
Petition for Rehearing Email
99 2025-04-03 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing(Appellant-Respondent)
Petition for Rehearing Email
100 2025-04-04 Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc(Appellant-Respondent)
Petition for Rehearing En Banc Email
101 2025-04-04 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Order Email to Counsel
102 2025-04-07 Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for motion for extension)
Filing Fee
103 2025-04-10 Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for respondent/appellant's PFR)
Filing Fee
104 2025-04-15 Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for appellant/respondent's PFR)
Filing Fee
105 2025-04-17 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)(for respondent Berry Beatty's PFR)
Motion Email Filing Fee
106 2025-04-18 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Order Email to Counsel
107 2025-05-02 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing(respondent Betty Beatty)
Petition for Rehearing Email
108 2025-05-12 Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for Respondent Betty Beatty's PFR)
Filing Fee
109 2025-05-19 Correspondence - Outgoing (Request for Returns)
Request for Returns Email to Counsel
110 2025-05-27 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(to file return; filed by Respondent-Appellants)
Motion Email
111 2025-05-27 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(to file return; filed by Appellant-Respondent)
Motion Email
112 2025-05-29 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(file by respondent Betty Beatty - return to appellant-respondent's PFR)
Motion Email
113 2025-05-29 Rehearing - Return(Appellant-Respondent - return to both Respondent-Appellants and Respondent Betty Beatty's PFRs)
Return to Petition for Rehearing Email
114 2025-06-02 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing fee for Resp-App Extension request)
Filing Fee
115 2025-06-02 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order(Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(to file return; filed by Appellant-Respondent))
Order Email to Counsel
116 2025-06-02 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted(Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(to file return; filed by Respondent-Appellants))
Order Email to Counsel
117 2025-06-02 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted(Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(file by respondent Betty Beatty - return to appellant-respondent's PFR))
Order Email to Counsel
118 2025-06-06 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing fee for Resp Betty Beatty's motion)
Filing Fee
119 2025-06-06 Rehearing - Return(filed by Respondents-Appellants)
Return to Petition for Rehearing Email
120 2025-06-09 Rehearing - Return(filed by respondent Betty Beatty)
Return to Petition for Rehearing Email
121 2025-06-09 Motion - Allow Late Filing of return to petition for rehearing (filed by respondent Betty Beatty)
Motion Email
122 2025-06-11 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order(Motion - Allow Late Filing of return to petition for rehearing (filed by respondent Betty Beatty))
Order Email to Counsel
123 2025-06-12 Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for Appellant-Respondent's motion)
Filing Fee
124 2025-06-12 Correspondence - Incoming (filing fee for Respondent Beatty's motion)
Filing Fee
125 2025-07-30 Rehearing - Denied with Substitute Opinion
Rehearing - Denied with Substitute Opinion Email
126 2025-07-30 Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc - No Vote Requested
Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc - No Vote Requested
127 2025-07-30 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Opinion
128 2025-08-29 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion filed with Supreme Court)
Motion Email
129 2025-08-29 Correspondence - Incoming (Order from Supreme Court)
Order
130 2025-08-29 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion filed with Supreme Court)
Motion Email
131 2025-08-29 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion filed with Supreme Court)
Motion Proof of Service Email
132 2025-09-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for Betty Beatty filed with Supreme Court)
Petition for Writ of Certiorari filed with Supreme Court Proof of Service Email
133 2025-09-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for TCC filed with Supreme Court)
Petition for Writ of Certiorari filed with Supreme Court Proof of Service Email
134 2025-09-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for all other parties filed with Supreme Court)
Petition for Writ of Certiorari filed with Supreme Court Proof of Service Email
135 2025-09-22 Correspondence - Incoming (Letter from Supreme Court)
Letter from Supreme Court
136 2025-10-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Responses filed with Supreme Court)
Return filed with Supreme Court Email Return filed with Supreme Court Email
137 2025-10-30 Correspondence - Incoming (copy of Reply filed with Supreme Court)
Reply filed with Supreme Court Email
138 2025-11-12 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Reply filed with Supreme Court)
Reply filed with Supreme Court Email
139 2026-01-16 Correspondence - Incoming (Order from Supreme Court)
Order from Supreme Court
140 2026-01-20 Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
Remittitur Email to Counsel