← Index Overview
Supreme Court

2019-001900 (cons)

Supreme Court
C-Track →
PENDING

Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC v. Office of Regulatory Staff

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal —
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2019-11-15
Case Type Public Service Commission Case Subtype Public Utility Rates
Filed Date — Argument Date —
Disposition Date — Remittitur Date —
Last Action Event 2022-02-01
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2019-11-15 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (Duke Energy)
Notice of Appeal Cover Letter and Receipt 91445 Transmittal Letter to the Public Service Commission
2 2019-11-15 Transcript Documents - No Transcript to be Ordered
—
3 2019-11-18 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal initial letter)
Correspondence Outgoing
4 2019-11-19 Correspondence - Outgoing (Pro Hac Vice Letter)
Correspondence Outgoing
5 2019-11-20 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Cross Appeal (SC Energy Users Committee)
Notice of Appeal - Cross Appeal Cover Letter and Receipt 91479
6 2019-11-20 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Third (The South Carolina Office of Regulatory Staff)
Notice of Appeal Cover Letter
7 2019-11-21 Correspondence - Outgoing Letter - Multiple Notices of Appeal Received
Correspondence Outgoing
8 2019-12-04 Motion - Joint Motion for Extended Briefing Schedule
Joint Motion for Extended Briefing Schedule Cover Letters and Receipt 91612
9 2019-12-18 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order issued on Joint Motion for Extended Briefing Schedule
Non Dispositional Decision Order
10 2019-12-18 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed Order on Joint Motion for Extended Briefing Schedule)
Outgoing Order
11 2020-01-08 Correspondence - Incoming Notice of Appearance and Request to Withdraw Stinson Woodward Ferguson as Counsel - no longer employed with Southern Environmental Law Center.
Correspondence Incoming
12 2020-01-08 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) Joint Motion to Extend Briefing Schedule Deadlines
Joint Motion to Extend Briefing Schedule Deadlines Cover Letter
13 2020-01-10 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Joint Motion for an Extension
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
14 2020-01-10 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order granting Joint Motion for an Extension)
Outgoing Order
15 2020-01-17 Correspondence - Incoming letter advising attorneys admitted pro hac vice before the SC Public Service Commission will not be participating in the appeal before this Court.
Correspondence Incoming
16 2020-01-17 Correspondence - Outgoing letter advising no action will be taken on request to relieve counsel.
Correspondence Outgoing
17 2020-01-24 Consent Motion to Consolidate with 2019-001904 and to Exceed Page Limitations for Principal Briefs
Consent Motion to Consolidate with 2019-001904 and to Exceed Page Limitations for Principal Briefs Cover Letter
18 2020-02-12 Motion - Joint Motion for Extending Briefing Schedule
Joint Motion for Extending Briefing Schedule Cover Letter and Receipt 92148
19 2020-02-20 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Motion to Consolidate and Exceed Page Limitations for Principal Briefs
Non Dispositional Decision Order
20 2020-02-20 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed Order granting Motion to Consolidate and Exceed Page Limitations)
Outgoing Order
21 2020-02-20 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
22 2020-02-20 Correspondence - Outgoing (extension order)
Outgoing Extension Order
23 2020-02-25 Correspondence - Incoming response to this Court's letter dated January 17, 2020.
Correspondence Incoming - Fax Correspondence Incoming - Original
24 2020-03-10 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting request to withdraw Stinson Woodward Ferguson as counsel.
Non Dispositional Decision Order
25 2020-03-10 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed order withdrawing Ms. Ferguson as counsel)
Outgoing Order
26 2020-03-10 Consent Motion to Withdraw Appeal filed by South Carolina Office of Regulatory Staff
Consent Motion to Withdraw Appeal Cover Letter
27 2020-03-24 Motion - No Return
—
28 2020-04-21 Initial Brief - Appellant - SC Energy Users
Initial Brief of Appellant - SC Energy Users Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter
29 2020-04-21 Designation of Matter - SC Energy Users
Designation of Matter - SC Energy Users Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter
30 2020-04-24 Initial Brief - Appellant - Duke Energy Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress
Initial Brief of Appellant - Duke Energy Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter and Envelope
31 2020-04-24 Designation of Matter - Duke Energy Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress
Designation of Matter - Duke Energy Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter and Envelope
32 2020-04-24 Correspondence - Incoming Notice of Appearance - Heather Shirley Smith
Notice of Appearance
33 2020-04-29 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order - Motion to withdraw the appeal is granted, and the notices of appeal filed by South Carolina Office of Regulatory Staff are dismissed.
Non Dispositional Decision Order
34 2020-04-29 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed Order granting Motion to Withdraw Appeal)
Outgoing Order
35 2020-05-05 Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
Correspondence Returned as Undeliverable
36 2020-05-14 Correspondence - Returned as undeliverable
Correspondence Returned as Undeliverable
37 2020-05-15 Remittitur - PARTIAL REMITTITUR - Appeals filed by the South Carolina Office of Regulatory Staff dismissed by Order dated April 29, 2020.
Partial Remittitur
38 2020-05-15 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed partial remittitur)
Outgoing Partial Remittitur
39 2020-06-01 Motion to Extend Briefing Schedule and Shorten Response Time
Motion to Extend Briefing Schedule and Shorten Response Time Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter
40 2020-06-09 Motion - E-mail responses to Motion to Extend Briefing Schedule and Response Time
E-Mail Responses to Motion to Extend Briefing Schedule and Response Time
41 2020-06-12 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Motion to Extend Briefing Schedule - Motion to Shorten Time to File a Response is denied as moot.
Non Dispositional Decision Order
42 2020-07-06 Initial Brief - Respondent - SC Office of Regulatory Staff
Initial Brief of Respondent - SC Office of Regulatory Staff Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter E-mail Transmittal
43 2020-07-06 Designation of Matter - SC Office of Regulatory Staff
Respondent\'s Designation of Matter - SC Office of Regulatory Staff Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter E-mail Transmittal
44 2020-07-09 Initial Brief - Respondent - Duke Energy Carolinas
Initial Brief of Respondent - Duke Energy Carolinas Proof of Service Certificate E-Mail Transmittal Cover Letter and Envelope
45 2020-07-09 Designation of Matter- Duke Energy Carolinas
Designation of Matter - Duke Energy Carolinas Proof of Service Certificate E-Mail Transmittal Cover Letter and Envelope
46 2020-08-11 Initial Brief - Reply
Initial Reply Brief Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter
47 2020-08-11 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter
48 2020-08-11 Initial Brief - Reply
Initial Reply Brief Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter E-Mail Transmittal
49 2020-08-11 Initial Brief - Initial Briefing Complete
—
50 2020-08-28 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Amended Designation of Matter Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter E-Mail Transmittal
51 2020-09-04 Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
Proof of Service of the Record on Appeal E-Mail Transmittal
52 2020-09-18 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae
Motion to Appear as Amicus Curiae Proof of Service Certificate E-Mail Transmittal
53 2020-09-18 Brief - Amicus
Amicus Curiae Brief Proof of Service Certificate E-Mail Transmittal
54 2020-09-21 Correspondence - Incoming letter enclosing filing fee for Amicus Curiae Motion
Correspondence Incoming Receipt 93280
55 2020-09-21 Record - Record on Appeal Filed
Record on Appeal Volume I Record on Appeal Volume II Record on Appeal Volume III Record on Appeal Volume IV Record on Appeal Volume V Record on Appeal Volume VI Record on Appeal Volume VII Record on Appeal Volume VIII Record on Appeal Volume IX Record on Appeal Volume X Record on Appeal Volume XI Record on Appeal Volume XII Record on Appeal Volume XIII Certificate of Counsel Cover Letter
56 2020-09-21 Record - Appendix to the Record on Appeal - Duke Energy
Appendix to the Record on Appeal - Duke Energy Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter
57 2020-09-21 Final Brief - Appellant - Duke Energy
Final Brief of Appellant - Duke Energy Proof of Service Certificate Certificate of Counsel Cover Letter
58 2020-09-21 Final Brief - Respondent - Duke Energy
Final Brief of Respondent - Duke Energy Proof of Service Certificate Certificate of Counsel Cover Letter
59 2020-09-21 Final Brief - Reply - Duke Energy
Final Reply Brief - Duke Energy Proof of Service Certificate Certificate of Counsel Cover Letter
60 2020-09-24 Final Brief - Respondent-Appellant (SCEUC)
Brief - Respondent-Appellant Proof of Service Certificate of Counsel Cover Email Cover Letter
61 2020-09-24 Final Brief - Reply of Respondent-Appellant - (SCEUC)
Reply Proof of Service Certificate of Counsel
62 2020-09-24 Final Brief - Respondent (SCORS)
Brief of Respondent Proof of Service Cover Letter Certificate of Counsel Cover Email Proof of Service Cover Email
63 2020-09-24 Record - Second Appendix (SCORS)(Supplemental)
Second Appendix Proof of Service Email
64 2020-09-24 Designation of Matter - Supplemental (SCORS)
Designation of Matter Proof of Service Proof of Service Email
65 2020-09-28 Final Brief - Briefing and Record Complete
—
66 2020-09-30 Motion - No Return
—
67 2020-10-16 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Amicus Curiae motion
Non Dispositional Decision Order
68 2020-10-16 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed Order granting Amicus Curiae motion)
Correspondence Outgoing
69 2020-10-27 Correspondence - Incoming letter enclosing (10) bound copies of amicus curiae brief
Correspondence Incoming
70 2020-10-29 Brief - No Amicus Reply
—
71 2020-12-10 Motion - Letter treated as a Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel
Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel Proof of Service Certificate E-Mail Transmittal
72 2020-12-15 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel
Non Dispositional Decision Order
73 2020-12-15 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed Order granting Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel to all counsel of record)
Outgoing Order
74 2020-12-17 Supplemental Citations - Received
Supplemental Citation Cover Letter E-Mail Transmittal
75 2020-12-21 Correspondence - Incoming (Response to supplemental authority letter)
Response to Supplemental Citation Proof of Service
76 2021-02-16 Motion - Withdraw as Counsel
Motion Proof of Service Cover Email Receipt
77 2021-02-17 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion to Withdraw Counsel
Order
78 2021-02-17 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Only)
Order
79 2021-02-19 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee Letter)
Letter
80 2021-04-12 Correspondence - Incoming (Other)
Cover Email Correspondence
81 2021-04-13 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter)
Letter
82 2021-05-14 Correspondence - Outgoing (Time Limit Letters to Counsel)
Letter
83 2021-05-19 Correspondence - Incoming (Bobby Stepp and Frank Ellerbe attending for Duke Energy)
Email
84 2021-05-19 Correspondence - Incoming (Andrew M. Bateman attending with Wallace Lightsey, arguing for SCORS)
Email
85 2021-05-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Scott Elliott arguing for SCEUC)
Email
86 2021-05-26 Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
—
87 2021-10-27 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Op. 28066 Duke Energy v.pdf
88 2021-11-05 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Rehearing)(15 days)
Motion Proof of Service Receipt
89 2021-11-08 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
Order
90 2021-11-08 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Only)
Order
91 2021-11-08 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee Letter)
Filing Fee Letter
92 2021-11-29 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing (App-Resp)
Rehearing (App-Resp) Proof of Service Cover Letter Cover Email Receipt
93 2021-12-08 Correspondence - Incoming (Email from Consumer Affairs: Not participating)
Email
94 2021-12-09 Rehearing - Return (Resp. ORS)
Return to Petition for Rehearing Proof of Service Cover Email Cover Letter
95 2022-02-01 Rehearing - Denied
Rehearing Order
96 2022-02-01 Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
Remittitur Sent