Supreme Court

2019-001596

Supreme Court

PENDING

Nationwide v. Sharmin Walls

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal	—
Case Group	Certiorari - COA	Initial Docket Date	2019-09-20
Case Type	Common Pleas	Case Subtype	Other
Filed Date	—	Argument Date	—
Disposition Date	—	Remittitur Date	—
Last Action Event	2021-07-06

Seq	Filing Date	Filing Entry	Files
1	2019-09-20	Petition for Writ of Certiorari and Responses - Petition and Appendix	Petition for a Writ of Certiorari Cover Letter and Receipt 90911 Appendix (Redacted)
2	2019-09-24	Correspondence - Outgoing (Petition for a Writ of Certiorari initial letter)	Correspondence Outgoing
3	2019-09-24	Correspondence - Incoming letter enclosing copy of redacted appendix	Correspondence Incoming
4	2019-10-09	Petition for Writ of Certiorari and Responses - Return	Return to Petition for a Writ of Certiorari Cover Letter Corrected Cover Page and Proof of Service
5	2019-10-28	Petition for Writ of Certiorari and Responses - No Reply	—
6	2020-02-12	Non-Dispositional Decision - Certiorari Granted	Certiorari Granted Order
7	2020-02-12	Correspondence - Outgoing (Certiorari Granted Order)	Outgoing Order
8	2020-03-09	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) to serve and file brief of petitioner and additional copies of the appendix	Receipt 92390 Motion for Extension
9	2020-03-11	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted - Brief of petitioner and additional copies of the appendix due March 23, 2020.	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
10	2020-03-11	Correspondence - Outgoing (extension order)	Outgoing Extension Order
11	2020-03-18	Brief - Petitioners Walls and Harper, and additional copies of the appendix	Brief of Petitioner Walls and Harper Cover Letter
12	2020-05-07	Brief - Respondent Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company	Brief of Respondent Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter
13	2020-06-15	Brief - No Reply	—
14	2020-09-23	Correspondence - Incoming (10 copies of brief of respondent)	Cover Letter
15	2020-10-14	Correspondence - Outgoing (Time Limit Notification Letter)	Letter
16	2020-10-27	Correspondence - Outgoing letter to counsel outlining procedures to be followed during presentation of oral arguments. Correct caption language is also included in this letter.	Correspondence Outgoing
17	2020-11-02	Correspondence - Incoming from J. R. Murphy advising the Court he will be appear and present the oral argument on behalf of the respondent in this matter.	Correspondence Incoming
18	2020-11-09	Correspondence - Incoming letter from J. Kirkman Morehead advising he will appear and present the oral arguments on behalf of the petitioners.	Correspondence Incoming
19	2020-11-12	Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae - United Policyholders	Motion to Appear as Amicus Curiae - United Policyholders Cover Letter E-Mail Transmittal
20	2020-11-12	Brief - Amicus - United Policyholders	Amicus Curiae Brief - United Policyholders Cover Letter E-Mail Transmittal
21	2020-11-16	Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae - South Carolina Association for Justice	Motion to Appear as Amicus Curiae - South Carolina Association for Justice Proof of Service Certificate E-Mail Transmittal
22	2020-11-16	Brief - Amicus - South Carolina Association for Justice	Amicus Curiae Brief - South Carolina Association for Justice Proof of Service Certificate E-Mail Transmittal
23	2020-11-17	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting amicus curiae motion filed on behalf of United Policyholders	Non Dispositional Decision Order
24	2020-11-17	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting amicus curiae motion filed on behalf of The South Carolina Association for Justice	Non Dispositional Decision Order
25	2020-11-18	Correspondence - Incoming filing fee for amicus curiae motion	Correspondence Incoming Receipt 93548
26	2020-11-19	Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held	—
27	2020-11-20	Correspondence - Incoming filing fee for amicus curiae motion	Correspondence Incoming Receipt 93554
28	2020-11-23	Correspondence - Incoming letter enclosing (10) bound copies of amicus curiae brief	Correspondence Incoming
29	2020-11-24	Motion - Supplement Record	Motion to Supplement Record Transcript in Support of Motion to Supplement Cover Letter E-Mail Transmittal Receipt
30	2020-11-30	Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee Cover Letter)	—
31	2020-11-30	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Motion to Supplement the Record	Non Dispositional Decision Order
32	2020-11-30	Correspondence - Outgoing - mailed Order granting Motion to Supplement the Record	Outgoing Order
33	2020-12-03	Brief - No Amicus Reply to South Carolina Association for Justice	—
34	2020-12-03	Brief - No Amicus Reply to United Policyholders	—
35	2021-03-10	Dispositional Decision - Opinion	Op. 28012 - Nationwide v. Sharmin Walls.docx
36	2021-03-25	Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing	Rehearing Proof of Service Cover Email
37	2021-03-29	Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee Cover Letter) with check	Filing Fee Cover Letter Receipt
38	2021-03-29	Motion - Extension of Time (Joint Extension)	Motion Cover Email
39	2021-04-02	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted	Extension order
40	2021-04-02	Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out extension order	Extension order sent out
41	2021-04-14	Rehearing - Return	Joint Return Cover Email Cover Email for Amicus Curiae
42	2021-06-03	Dispositional Decision - Substituted Opinion	Substituted opinion
43	2021-06-03	Correspondence - Outgoing email sending out opinion	email
44	2021-06-03	Remittitur - Remittitur Sent	Remitittur
45	2021-06-03	Correspondence - Outgoing sending remitttitur	Email sending out remittitur
46	2021-06-04	Motion - Costs (Walls)	Cover email Transmittal letter Motion for Costs Itemized statement Proof of service Receipt
47	2021-06-04	Motion - Costs (petitioner)	Transmittal email Transmittal letter Motion for Costs Itemized statement Certificate of service Receipt
48	2021-06-14	Motion - Return	Return to Motion Cover Email
49	2021-07-06	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order on costs	Order on costs
50	2021-07-06	Correspondence - Outgoing on costs	Email sending out costs