← Index Overview
Supreme Court

2019-000238

Supreme Court
C-Track →
PENDING

Ex Parte: Builders Mutual (In Re: Palmetto Pointe v. Island Pointe)

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal —
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2019-02-19
Case Type Common Pleas Case Subtype Other
Filed Date — Argument Date —
Disposition Date — Remittitur Date —
Last Action Event 2020-08-31
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2019-02-19 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial
notice of appeal order (1/17/19) order (12/18/18)
2 2019-02-20 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Second
notice of appeal order(s) Amended Proof of Service and cover letter
3 2019-02-22 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter)
notice of appeal initial letter
4 2019-02-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Third
notice of appeal order(s)
5 2019-02-22 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Fourth
order(s) notice of appeal
6 2019-02-25 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
transcript order to Ms. Lauder transcript order to Ms. Norton
7 2019-02-27 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion to Certify Filed in the Supreme Court)
copy of motion
8 2019-03-06 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Appeal Initial Letter - Multiple Notices Received Letter)
notice of appeal initial letter
9 2019-03-06 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Third)
deficiency letter
10 2019-03-06 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Fourth)
deficiency letter
11 2019-03-07 Correspondence - Incoming letter enclosing correct filing fees for Notices of Appeal.
letter
12 2019-03-08 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion to Transfer Filed in Supreme Court)
copy of motion to transfer
13 2019-03-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion to Transfer to Supreme Court)
copy of motion
14 2019-03-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Motion to Transfer to Supreme Court)
copy of motion
15 2019-04-16 Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal
Transcript delivered
16 2019-04-26 Motion - Stay / Supersedeas (including lifting of automatic stay)
Motion
17 2019-04-29 Motion - Appellant Nautilus Insurance Company's Petition for Expedited Review of Order Lifting Stay
motion
18 2019-04-29 Appellant Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company's Petition for Review
petition for review cover letters
19 2019-04-29 Appellant Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company's Petition for Review
cover letter petition for review
20 2019-04-29 Correspondence - Outgoing requesting expedited returns
letter
21 2019-04-30 Motion - Respondents' Return to Petition of Appellant Builders Mutual Insurance Company for Review of Circuit Court Order Lifting Stay AND/OR Cross-Motion to Dismiss Appeal
return to motion AND motion return to motion AND motion - faxed copy
22 2019-04-30 Motion - Respondents' Return to Petition of Appellant Builders Mutual Insurance Company for Review of Circuit Court Order Lifting Stay And/or Cross-Motion to Dismiss Appeal, Grant Limited Remand, or Otherwise Confirm that Trial May Proceed as Scheduled
return to motion AND motion return to motion AND motion - faxed copy cover letter
23 2019-04-30 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Fifth
notice of appeal order
24 2019-05-01 Motion - Respondents' Response in Opposition to Nationwide Appellants' Petitions for Review of Circuit Court Order Lifting Stay
return to motion
25 2019-05-01 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motions to Stay, Petitions for Review, and Motions to Dismiss)
order
26 2019-05-02 Motion - Respondents' Return to Appellant Nautilus Insurance Company's Petition for Review of Circuit Court Order Lifting Stay
return to motion
27 2019-05-07 Motion - Respondents' Return to Nationwide Appellants' Petitions for review of Circuit Court Order Lifting Stay
return to motion
28 2019-05-13 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Appellant's Initial Brief of Builders Mutual Insurance Company)
motion for extension
29 2019-05-14 Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered
letter ordering transcript
30 2019-05-14 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Appellant's Initial Brief of Builders Mutual Insurance Company)
order
31 2019-05-14 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Appellant Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company's Initial Brief)
motion for extension
32 2019-05-14 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Appellant Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company's Initial Brief)
motion for extension
33 2019-05-14 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - Appellant Nautilus Insurance Company's Initial Brief)
motion for extension
34 2019-05-22 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (All Appellants' Initial Briefs)
order
35 2019-05-31 Transfer - To Supreme Court
Transfer Order
36 2019-06-04 Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Appeal Initial Letter - 5th NOA)
Notice of Appeal Initial Letter
37 2019-06-13 Initial Brief - Appellant (Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company)
Initial Brief - Appellant (Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company) Cover Letter
38 2019-06-13 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter Filed
39 2019-06-14 Initial Brief - Appellant (Builders Mutual Insurance Company)
Cover Letter Initial Brief - Appellant
40 2019-06-14 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed
Designation of Matter
41 2019-06-14 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)(On behalf of Nautilus Insurance pending receipt of settlement documents)
Motion for 2nd Extension Cover Letter Receipt
42 2019-06-14 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd)(On behalf of Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company pending settlement documents)
Motion for 2nd Extension Cover Letter Receipt 90028
43 2019-06-18 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Nationwide Mutual Fire) until July 5, 2019 to serve and file initial brief of appellant and designation of matter.
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
44 2019-06-18 Correspondence - Outgoing (extension order)
Outgoing Extension Order
45 2019-06-18 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Nautilus Insurance) until July 5, 2019 to serve and file initial brief of appellant and designation of matter.
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
46 2019-06-18 Correspondence - Outgoing (extension order)
Outgoing Extension Order
47 2019-06-24 Motion - Withdraw Appeal (Appellant FCCI Insurance Company)
Motion - Withdraw Appeal Cover Letter and Envelope Receipt
48 2019-06-24 Non-Dispositional Decision - Withdrawn (Appellant FCCI Insurance Company)
Withdrawn
49 2019-06-24 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Only)
Withdrawn
50 2019-06-26 Motion - Withdraw Appeal (Appellant Nautilus Insurance Company)
Motion - Withdraw Appeal Cover Receipt
51 2019-06-27 Non-Dispositional Decision - Withdrawn (Appellant Nautilus Insurance Company)
Order
52 2019-07-10 Correspondence - Outgoing (Partial Remittitur)(FCCI)
Partial Remittitur
53 2019-07-10 Motion - Withdraw Appeal (Appellant Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company)
Cover Letter Receipt Proof of Service to Motion w/ filing fee Emailed Consent Motion - Withdraw Appeal w/ Filing Fee
54 2019-07-12 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Tri-County Roofing, Inc.)
Motion for 1st Extension (w/ filing fee) Cover Letter and Envelope Receipt
55 2019-07-12 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love)
Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Palmetto Pointe) Cover Letter and Envelope Receipt
56 2019-07-15 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st)(Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love)
Order Granting 1st Extension
57 2019-07-15 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Only)(Palmetto Pointe)
Order Granting 1st Extension
58 2019-07-15 Motion - Motion to Dismiss or Hold in Abeyance Appeal of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company
Motion to Dismiss or Hold in Abeyance Appeal of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company Cover Letter and Receipt
59 2019-07-17 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st)(Tri-County Roofing)
Order Granting 1st Extension
60 2019-07-17 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Only)(Tri-County)
Order Granting 1st Extension
61 2019-07-17 Correspondence - Outgoing (Partial Remittitur)
Partial Remittitur
62 2019-07-18 Motion - Return to Motion to Dismiss or Hold in Abeyance Appeal of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company
Return to Motion to Dismiss or Hold in Abeyance Appeal of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company Cover Letter
63 2019-07-25 Motion - No Reply
—
64 2019-08-07 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Motion to Withdraw
Order Granting Motion to Withdraw
65 2019-08-07 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Granting Motion to Withdraw)
Order Granting Motion to Withdraw
66 2019-08-09 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) (Tri-County Roofing)
Motion for 2nd Extension Cover Letter and Envelope Receipt
67 2019-08-09 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (2nd) (Tri-County Roofing)
Order Granting 2nd Extension
68 2019-08-09 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Only)
Order Granting 2nd Extension
69 2019-08-28 Correspondence - Outgoing (Partial Remittitur)
Partial Remittitur
70 2019-09-05 Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice
Receipt Motion - Appear Pro Hac Vice
71 2019-09-05 Correspondence - Incoming (From Bar Admissions)
Incoming (From Bar Admissions)
72 2019-09-06 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae - Hartford
Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae - Hartford Cover Letter Receipt
73 2019-09-06 Brief - Amicus - Hartford
Brief - Amicus - Hartford
74 2019-09-10 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order Granting Pro Hac Vice
Order Granting Pro Hac Vice
75 2019-09-13 Initial Brief - Respondent (Tri-County Roofing, Inc.)
Initial Brief - Respondent Cover Letter and Envelope
76 2019-09-13 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)
Motion Original
77 2019-09-16 Motion - Extension of Time (1st)(Reply Brief)
Motion for 1st Extension Cover Letter
78 2019-09-16 Motion - Amended Extension of Time (1st)
Amended Extension of Time (1st) Envelope Receipt
79 2019-09-16 Motion - Return
Motion - Return Cover Letter
80 2019-09-17 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order
Order
81 2019-09-17 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (1st)(Reply Brief)
Order Granting 1st Extension
82 2019-09-26 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Motion to Appear as Amicus Curiae
Non Dispositional Decision Order
83 2019-09-26 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order granting Motion to Appear as Amicus Curiae)
Outgoing Order
84 2019-09-27 Correspondence - Incoming from counsel for Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. advising Court of developments which affect their pending appeal
Correspondence Incoming Cover Letter
85 2019-09-27 Motion for Clarification - Appellant Nationwide Mutual's Motion for Clarification to Preserve It's Right to Respond
Motion for Clarification Cover Letter Receipt 90993
86 2019-10-02 Initial Brief - Reply
Initial Reply Brief Cover Letter
87 2019-10-07 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order denying Motion to Dismiss Appeal of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company and advising parties of time limits pursuant to Motion for Clarification.
Non Dispositional Decision Order
88 2019-10-07 Correspondence - Outgoing (Order Denying Motion to Dismiss Appeal of Nationwide, etc)
Outgoing Order
89 2019-10-07 Motion - Return to Motion for Clarification
Return to Motion for Clarification Cover Letter
90 2019-10-11 Initial Brief - Respondent (Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love)
Initial Brief - Respondent (Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love) Cover Letter
91 2019-10-11 Designation of Matter - Respondent's Designation of Matter Filed (Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love)
Respondent\'s Designation of Matter Cover Letter
92 2019-10-11 Brief - Amicus Reply (Builders Mutual)
Brief - Amicus Reply - Builders Mutual Cover Letter
93 2019-10-11 Brief - Amicus Reply (Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love)
Brief - Amicus Reply - Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love Cover Letter
94 2019-10-18 Initial Brief - Reply (Builders Mutual)
Initial Reply Brief Cover Letter
95 2019-10-21 Initial Brief - Reply (Nationwide Mutual)
Initial Reply Brief Cover Letter
96 2019-10-21 Initial Brief - Initial Briefing Complete
—
97 2019-11-08 Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
Proof of Service of the Record on Appeal Cover Letter
98 2019-11-22 Record - Appendix to the Record on Appeal
Appendix to the Record on Appeal Cover Letter Proof of Service and Cover Letter
99 2019-11-25 Final Brief - Appellant - Nationwide Mutual Insurance
Final Brief - Appellant - Nationwide Mutual Insurance Cover Letter
100 2019-11-25 Final Brief - Reply - Nationwide Mutual Insurance
Final Brief - Reply - Nationwide Mutual Insurance Cover Letter
101 2019-11-25 Final Brief - Respondent - Tri-County Roofing
Final Brief - Respondent - Tri-County Roofing Cover Letter
102 2019-11-26 Record - Record on Appeal Filed
Record on Appeal Volume I Record on Appeal Volume II Cover Letter
103 2019-11-26 Final Brief - Appellant - Builders Mutual Insurance Company
Final Brief of Appellant - Builders Mutual Insurance Company Cover Letter
104 2019-11-26 Final Brief - Reply - Builders Mutual Insurance Company to Tri-County Roofing
Final Brief - Reply - Builders Mutual Insurance Company to Tri-County Roofing Cover Letter
105 2019-11-26 Final Brief - Reply - Builders Mutual Insurance Company to Palmetto Pointe
Final Brief - Reply - Builders Mutual Insurance Company to Palmetto Pointe Cover Letter
106 2019-11-26 Final Brief - Amicus Reply
Final Amicus Reply Brief Cover Letter
107 2019-11-27 Final Brief - Respondents - Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love
Final Brief of Respondents - Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love Cover Letter
108 2019-12-04 Final Brief - Briefing and Record Complete
—
109 2020-01-21 Correspondence - Outgoing Letter -Notify Counsel of Argument Time Limits
Outgoing Time Limit Letter
110 2020-01-30 Correspondence - Incoming letter from counsel for Nationwide requesting additional time to present oral arguments and split the time with counsel for Builders Mutual.
Correspondence Incoming
111 2020-02-05 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter advising counsel of adjusted time limits for oral arguments on behalf of appellants, Builders Mutual and Nationwide).
Correspondence Outgoing
112 2020-02-07 Correspondence - Incoming letter request from counsel for respondents requesting an additional (5) minutes to present oral argument.
Correspondence Incoming Fax Transmittal Correspondence Incoming (Original)
113 2020-02-10 Motion - Appear as Amicus Curiae - The SC Association for Justice
Motion to Appear as Amicus Curiae - The SC Association for Justice Cover Letter and Receipt 92127
114 2020-02-10 Brief - Amicus - The SC Association for Justice
—
115 2020-02-10 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed letter addressed to counsel for respondents advising of adjustment to time limits for oral arguments).
Correspondence Outgoing
116 2020-02-10 Motion of Hartford to Present Argument as Amicus Curiae
Motion of Hartford to Present Argument as Amicus Curiae Cover Letter and Receipt 92130
117 2020-02-10 Motion - Return to Motion of Hartford to Present Argument as Amicus Curiae
Return to Motion of Hartford to Present Argument as Amicus Curiae (E-mail) Cover Letter (E-mail) Return to Motion of Hartford to Present Argument as Amicus Curiae (Original) Cover Letter (Original)
118 2020-02-10 Correspondence - Incoming letter from counsel for Tri-County Roofing
Correspondence Incoming
119 2020-02-10 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order - Motion by Hartford to present argument as amicus curiae is denied.
Non Dispositional Decision Order
120 2020-02-10 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting amicus curiae motion on behalf of The South Carolina Association for Justice.
Non Dispositional Decision Order
121 2020-02-11 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed Order denying Motion by Hartford to present argument as amicus curiae)
Outgoing Order
122 2020-02-11 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed order granting amicus curiae motion)
Outgoing Order
123 2020-02-11 Oral Argument - Oral Argument Held
—
124 2020-02-13 Correspondence - Incoming letter addressed to the Court of Appeals and received via interagency mail.
Correspondence Incoming
125 2020-02-18 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) to serve and file reply to amicus curiae brief
Motion for Extension Cover Letter and Receipt 92183
126 2020-02-20 Brief - Amicus Reply - Nationwide
Brief- Amicus Reply - Nationwide Cover Letter
127 2020-02-20 Brief - Amicus Reply - Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love
Brief - Amicus Reply - Palmetto Pointe and Jack Love Cover Letter
128 2020-02-21 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted - Builder's Mutual reply to amicus curiae brief due March 2, 2020.
Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
129 2020-02-21 Correspondence - Outgoing (extension order)
Outgoing Extension Order
130 2020-03-02 Brief - Amicus Reply
Brief - Amicus Reply Cover Letter
131 2020-05-13 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Op. 27970 - Ex Parte Builders Mutual.docx
132 2020-05-13 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed opinion)
Outgoing Opinion
133 2020-05-28 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing
Petition for Rehearing - E-File Proof of Service Petition for Rehearing - Mail Cover Letter and Receipt 92773
134 2020-05-29 Correspondence - Outgoing E-MAILED REQUEST TO COUNSEL REQUESTING A RETURN TO THE PETITION FOR REHEARING
Memorandum
135 2020-06-16 Rehearing - Return - Nationwide Mutual
Return to Petition for Rehearing - Nationwide Mutual - Original Proof of Service Certificate - Original Cover Letter - Original
136 2020-06-19 Motion - Respondent's Motion to File a Consolidated Brief (Reply to Returns' to Petition for Rehearing)
Respondent\'s Motion to File a Consolidated Brief Proof of Service Certificate Receipt 92870
137 2020-06-22 Correspondence - Incoming e-mail from counsel advising they have obtained consent of counsel for Nationwide and Builders Mutual
Consent E-Mail
138 2020-06-22 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting Motion to File a Consolidated Reply
Non Dispositional Decision Order
139 2020-06-22 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed Order granting Motion to File a Consolidated Reply)
Outgoing Order
140 2020-06-24 Correspondence - Incoming letter enclosing filing fee for Motion to Consolidate
Correspondence Incoming Receipt
141 2020-06-25 Rehearing - Return - Builders Mutual
Return to Petition for Rehearing - Builders Mutual Proof of Service Certificate Cover Letter E-mail Transmittal
142 2020-07-02 Rehearing - Consolidated Reply to Return's to Petition for Rehearing
Consolidated Reply to Returns\' to Petition for Rehearing Proof of Service Certificate
143 2020-08-12 Rehearing - Granted with Re-Filed Opinion
Rehearing Granted With Re-Filed Opinion
144 2020-08-12 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed Order granting Petition for Rehearing and Re-Filed Opinion)
Outgoing Order and Re-Filed Opinion
145 2020-08-31 Rehearing - No Petition for Rehearing Filed - Remittitur to be Sent
—
146 2020-08-31 Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
Remittitur Order and Re-Filed Opinion
147 2020-08-31 Correspondence - Outgoing (mailed remittitur)
Outgoing Remittitur