← Index Overview
Court of Appeals

2017-002291 (cons)

Court of Appeals
C-Track →
PENDING

Deborah Harwell v. Robert Harwell (2)

Case Info

Lower Court / Tribunal —
Case Group Appeal Initial Docket Date 2017-11-02
Case Type Common Pleas Case Subtype Other
Filed Date — Argument Date —
Disposition Date — Remittitur Date —
Last Action Event 2022-02-24
Seq Filing Date Filing Entry Files
1 2017-11-02 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial (filed by Kevin Barth on behalf of Bryan Harwell)
notice of appeal order 10/2/2017 order 4/12/17
2 2017-11-08 Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Cross Appeal (filed by Desa Ballard on behalf of Deborah Harwell)
notice of cross appeal order 10/2/17 order 4/12/17
3 2017-11-08 Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (Desa Ballard & Harvey Watson, III)
motion
4 2017-11-08 Correspondence - Outgoing (notice of appeal initial letter)
outgoing corrrespondence
5 2017-11-14 Correspondence - Outgoing (Caption correction - cross appeal)
outgoing correspondence
6 2017-11-21 Correspondence - Outgoing (transcript warning letter)
outgoing correspondence
7 2017-11-27 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order
order
8 2017-11-29 Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal
transcript documents
9 2017-12-05 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance for appellant/respondent - Blake Hewitt)
incoming correspondence
10 2017-12-29 Correspondence - Incoming (From former counsel Desa Ballard)
incoming correpsondence
11 2018-01-08 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - To obtain counsel and file initial brief of Deborah Harwell)
motion
12 2018-01-08 Correspondence - Outgoing (Initial briefing schedule reinstated)
outgoing correspondence
13 2018-01-09 Motion - Consolidate appeals 2017-002290 & 2017-002291 and correct caption
motion
14 2018-01-11 Correspondence - Outgoing (held in abeyance pending decision on motion to consolidate)
outgoing correspondence
15 2018-01-22 Motion - Return to Motion to Consolidate Appeals 2017-002290 & 2017-002291 and correct caption
Return (faxed copy) return (original copy rec\'d 1/24)
16 2018-01-26 Motion - Reply to Return to Motion to Consolidate Appeals 2017-002290 & 2017-002291 and correct caption
Reply
17 2018-02-07 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion to consolidate (2017-002290)
order letter
18 2018-02-07 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting extension and setting briefing timeline
order
19 2018-02-07 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion to consolidate (2017-002291)
order
20 2018-02-15 Correspondence - Incoming (letter from counsel for Robert Harwell, clarifying the briefing deadlines)
incoming correspondence
21 2018-02-28 Motion - Extension of Time (1st appellants initial brief of respondent/appellant, Robert Harwell)
motion
22 2018-03-01 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
order
23 2018-03-27 Correspondence - Outgoing (appellant's initial brief of respondent/appellant (Deborah Harwell) overdue)
outgoing corresondence
24 2018-04-06 Initial Brief - Appellant (respondent/appellant - Robert Harwell)
appellants initial brief of Robert Harwell
25 2018-04-06 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by respondent/appellant (Robert Harwell)
designation of matter
26 2018-04-06 Motion - Extension of Time (2nd - appellants initial brief of respondent/appellant (Deborah Harwell)
motion for extension (faxed copy) motion for extension (original copy rec\'d 4/9)
27 2018-04-06 Motion - Allow Late Filing of the motion for an extension filed by Respondent/Appellant, Deborah Harwell
motion (faxed copy) motion (original copy rec\'d 4/9)
28 2018-04-11 Correspondence - Outgoing (Returning money orders for an address)
outgoing correspondence
29 2018-04-17 Correspondence - Incoming (Deborah Harwell's filing fees for motions)
incoming correspondence
30 2018-04-23 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
order
31 2018-04-26 Correspondence - Outgoing (Briefing schedule held in abeyance until respondent/appellant files appellant's initial brief)
outgoing correspondence
32 2018-06-08 Initial Brief - Appellant (respondent/appellant - Deborah Harwell)
appellants initial brief (faxed copy) appellants initial brief (original copy rec\'d 6/11)
33 2018-06-08 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by respondent/appellant Deborah Harwell
designation of matter (faxed copy) designation of matter (original copy rec\'d 6/11)
34 2018-06-12 Correspondence - Outgoing (Cross appeal briefing schedule reinstated)
outgoing correspondence
35 2018-06-13 Motion - Other Motion to Amended Appellant's Initial Brief of Deborah Harwell
motion
36 2018-06-13 (AMENDED) Initial Brief - Appellant (Deborah Harwell)
AMENDED appellants initial brief
37 2018-07-03 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion to amend appellants initial brief of Deborah Harwell Granted)
order
38 2018-07-31 Initial Brief - Respondent (respondent/appellant, Robert Bryan Harwell)
respondents initial brief of respondent/appellant Robert Harwell
39 2018-07-31 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent/Appellant - Robert Bryan Harwell
designation of matter
40 2018-08-06 Initial Brief - Respondent (Appellants/Respondents - Law Office of Deirdre Edmonds, P.A. and Deirdre Edmonds, individually)
Respondents initial brief of appellants/respondents
41 2018-08-06 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by appellants/respondents - Law Office of Deirdre Edmonds and Deirdre Edmonds, individually)
designation of matter
42 2018-08-06 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - initial reply brief of Appellants/Respondents - Law Office of Deirdre Edmonds and Deirdre Edmonds, Individually)
motion
43 2018-08-08 Correspondence - Outgoing (respondents initial brief of respondent/appellant Deborah Harwell overdue letter)
outgoing correspondence
44 2018-08-09 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
order
45 2018-08-13 Motion - Extension of Time (1st - initial reply brief of respondent/appellant - Robert Bryan Harwell)
motion
46 2018-08-14 Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter acknowledging receipt of the motion for extension - Court will act on motion after August 20, 2018)
outgoing correspondence
47 2018-08-27 Initial Brief - Reply (appellants/respondents - Deirdre Edmonds and Law Office of Deidre Edmonds)
initial reply brief of appellants/respondents
48 2018-08-27 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by appellants/respondents - Deirdre Edmonds and Law Office of Deirdre Edmonds
designation of matter
49 2018-08-29 Initial Brief - No Respondent Brief filed by respondent/appellant Deborah Harwell
—
50 2018-08-29 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted
order
51 2018-09-03 Correspondence - Incoming (Respondent/Appellant, Deborah Harwell's, letter regarding the time for an initial reply brief.)
incoming correspondence incoming correspondence (original copy rec\'d 9/6)
52 2018-09-05 Correspondence - Outgoing (Court's response to Ms. Harwell's letter regarding the time for an initial reply brief)
outgoing correspondence
53 2018-09-17 Initial Brief - Reply of Respondent/Appellant Robert Bryan Harwell
initial reply brief of Robert Bryan Harwell
54 2018-09-17 Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent/Appellant Robert Bryan Harwell
designation of matter
55 2018-09-17 Motion - Allow Late Filing of the initial reply brief of Robert Bryan Harwell
motion
56 2018-09-26 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion to allow late filing of Robert Bryan Harwells initial reply brief
order
57 2018-10-05 Motion - Strike filed by respondent/appellant, Robert Bryan Harwell
motion
58 2018-10-16 Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal
proof of service of the record on appeal
59 2018-11-01 Final Brief - Appellant (Respondent/Appellant R. Bryan Harwell)
appellants final brief of respondent/appellant R. Bryan Harwell proof of service cover letter
60 2018-11-01 Final Brief - Respondent (Respondent/Appellant R. Bryan Harwell)
respondents final brief of respondent/appellant R. Bryan Harwell proof of service cover letter
61 2018-11-01 Final Brief - Reply (Respondent/Appellant R. Bryan Harwell)
final reply brief of respondent/appellant R. Bryan Harwell proof of service cover letter
62 2018-11-02 Record - Record on Appeal Filed
(AMENDED) record on appeal volume I (AMENDED) record on appeal volume II cover letter certificate of counsel proof of service
63 2018-11-02 Final Brief - Appellant (Appellant/Respondent - Law Office of Deidre Edmunds and Deidre Edmunds individually)
(AMENDED) appellants final brief of the appellant/respondent (AMENDED) proof of service
64 2018-11-02 Final Brief - Respondent (Appellant/Respondent - Law Office of Deidre Edmunds and Deidre Edmunds individually)
(AMENDED) respondents final brief of the appellant/respondent (AMENDED) proof of service
65 2018-11-02 Final Brief - Reply (Appellant/Respondent - Law Office of Deidre Edmunds and Deidre Edmunds individually)
(AMENDED) final reply brief of the appellant/respondent (AMENDED) proof of service
66 2018-11-26 Motion - Other Appellants/Respondents Motion for Leave to File Corrected Final Briefs and the Record on Appeal
motion
67 2018-11-27 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent regarding motion for leave to file corrected final briefs and the record on appeal
deficiency letter
68 2018-11-30 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting the motion to strike and motion to file corrected final brief and record on appeal
order cover letter
69 2018-12-03 Deficiency - Correction regarding the motion for leave to file corrected final briefs and the record on appeal
deficiency correction
70 2018-12-20 Correspondence - Incoming (appellants/respondents proof of service for the corrected record on appeal)
incoming correspondence
71 2018-12-27 Correspondence - Incoming (appellants/respondents certificate of counsel for the corrected record on appeal)
Certificate of Counsel
72 2019-01-15 Correspondence - Outgoing (Time for Appellant's Final Brief of Respondent/Appellant-Deborah B. Harwell-Expired)
Letter
73 2019-01-18 Correspondence - Incoming (Regarding Deborah Harwell Obtaining Counsel)
Letter
74 2019-01-28 Correspondence - Incoming (Address Change)
Letter
75 2019-02-01 Correspondence - Incoming (Regarding Address Change)
Letter Letter (Copy)
76 2019-02-01 Correspondence - Outgoing (Resent 1/15/2019 Letter to Deborah Harwell)
Letter
77 2019-02-05 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (File Amended Record on Appeal)
Motion (Fax) Motion (Original-Addressed to Clerk) Motion (Original-Addressed to Case Owner)
78 2019-02-08 Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (File Motion Out of Time for Appellant's Final Brief)
Letter
79 2019-02-14 Correspondence - Incoming (Regarding Deborah Harwell Filing a Motion)
Letter Letter (2) Letter (2) - Addressed to Clerk Letter (2) - Faxed
80 2019-02-19 Correspondence - Incoming (Regarding 2/8/2019 Deficiency Letter)
Letter
81 2019-02-19 Motion - Hold in Abeyance and Appoint Counsel
Motion
82 2019-02-26 Motion - Return (Hold in Abeyance)
Return to Motion
83 2019-03-04 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion Appoint Counsel-Denied AND Motion for Extension-Granted)
Order
84 2019-04-01 Motion - Remand and Declaration of a Mistrial
Motion
85 2019-04-04 Motion - Return (Remand and Declaration of a Mistrial)
Return to Motion
86 2019-04-22 Motion - No Reply (Remand and Declaration of a Mistrial)
—
87 2019-06-05 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order (Motion to Remand and Declaration of a Mistrial-Denied)
Order
88 2019-06-27 Final Brief - Appellant (Respondent/Appellant Deborah B. Harwell)
Appellant\'s Final Brief Proof of Service
89 2019-10-16 Motion - Withdraw as Counsel (Blake A. Hewitt, Esq.)
Motion
90 2019-10-29 Motion - No Return (Withdraw as Counsel (Blake A. Hewitt, Esq.))
—
91 2019-10-29 Non-Dispositional Decision - Order - Withdraw as Counsel (Blake A. Hewitt, Esq.) Granted
Order
92 2020-04-08 Dispositional Decision - Opinion
Cover Letter
93 2020-04-24 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing
Petition for Rehearing Petition for Rehearing (Original)
94 2020-04-24 Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc
Petition for Rehearing En Banc
95 2020-04-24 Correspondence - Outgoing (Requesting Return to Petition for Rehearing)
Letter
96 2020-04-27 Correspondence - Incoming (Filing Fee Deborah Harwell Petition for Rehearing)
Filing Fee
97 2020-04-29 Rehearing - Petition for Rehearing
Petition for Rehearing
98 2020-04-29 Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc
Petition for Rehearing En Banc
99 2020-04-30 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Respondent/Appellant Petition for Rehearing)
Motion Motion (Copy)
100 2020-04-30 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance)
Notice of Appearance
101 2020-05-01 Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Respondent/Appellant Return to Petition for Rehearing)
Order
102 2020-05-04 Correspondence - Incoming (Notice of Appearance)
Letter
103 2020-05-06 Correspondence - Outgoing (Requesting Return to Appellants-Respondents Petition for Rehearing)
Letter
104 2020-05-14 Rehearing - Return (To Respondent/Appellant's Rehearing)
Return Proof of Service Return (Original)
105 2020-05-14 Rehearing - Return (To Appellants/Respondents Rehearing)
Return Return (Original)
106 2020-05-22 Correspondence - Outgoing (Returning Filing Fee)
Letter
107 2020-06-08 Rehearing - Reply (To Appellants/Respondents Rehearing)
Reply
108 2020-07-02 Motion - Extension of Time (1st) (Reply to Return to Petition for Rehearing-Respondent/Appellant)
Motion
109 2020-07-09 Correspondence - Outgoing (No Action on Motion for Extension - Reply to Petition for Rehearing)
Letter
110 2020-10-07 Rehearing - Denied (Deborah Harwell)
Order
111 2020-10-07 Rehearing - Granted (Law Office of Deidre W. Edmonds, P.A. and Deidre W. Edmonds, Individually)
Order
112 2020-10-07 Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc - No Vote Requested
Letter
113 2020-10-07 Dispositional Decision - Opinion (REFILED)
Refiled opinion
114 2020-10-21 Rehearing - Respondent/Appellant Robert Bryan Harwell's Petition for Partial Rehearing
Petition for Partial Rehearing Email From Counsel Petition for Rehearing (Copy)
115 2020-10-21 Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc (Respondent/Appellant Robert Bryan Harwell)
Suggesion for Rehearing En Banc Email from Counsel
116 2020-11-17 Rehearing - No Return
—
117 2020-11-18 Rehearing - Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc - Denied
No Vote Letter Email to Counsel
118 2020-11-18 Rehearing - Granted with Substitute Opinion
Order Email to Counsel
119 2020-11-18 Dispositional Decision - Opinion (REFILED)
Opinion - Refiled Email to Counsel
120 2020-12-15 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Notice of Appeal to Supreme Court)
Notice of Appeal
121 2020-12-17 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Petition for Writ of Certiorari)
Petition for Writ of Certiorari Email Amended Proof of Service Email (2) Petition for Writ of Certiorari (Originial) Proof of Service (Original)
122 2020-12-21 Motion - Dismiss (Sent to Supreme Court)
Motion Motion (Original with Fee) Memorandum in Support
123 2021-01-20 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Reply to Return to Petition for Rehearing)
Reply to Petition Reply to Petition (Original)
124 2021-03-31 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Dismissal Order from Supreme Court-Deborah Harwell)
Order
125 2021-04-23 Remittitur - Remittitur Sent (PARTIAL)
Partial Remittitur Email to Counsel
126 2021-12-10 Correspondence - Incoming (Copy of Supreme Court Order Denying Petition for Writ of Certiorari)
Order
127 2021-12-13 Remittitur - Remittitur Sent
Remittitur Email to Counsel
128 2022-01-28 Correspondence - Incoming (Requesting 60 Days to Respond)
Letter
129 2022-02-24 Correspondence - Outgoing (No Action on Letter Requesting 60 Days)
Letter Email to Counsel