2016-001198

Seq	Filing Date	Filing Entry	Files
1	2016-06-06	Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial	notice of appeal order under appeal order under appeal
2	2016-06-07	Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered	letter ordering the transcript from the court reporter (1 of 2) letter ordering the transcript from the court reporter (2 of 2)
3	2016-06-09	Correspondence - Incoming (Other) agreement to dismiss party	correspondence
4	2016-06-10	Correspondence - Outgoing notice of appeal initial letter	notice of appeal initial letter
5	2016-06-28	Deficiency - Correction - proof of service of agreement to dismiss party	deficiency correction (proof of service)
6	2016-07-28	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order dismissing Richland Lexington School District No.5 Board of Trustees as a party to this appeal.	order
7	2016-07-28	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order denying motion to consolidate / motion filed in case # 2016-000211	order
8	2016-08-03	Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel	motion
9	2016-08-08	Transcript Documents - Notification that Transcript has not been Received	correspondence
10	2016-08-15	Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal	letter confirming receipt of the transcript
11	2016-08-15	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion	order cover letter
12	2016-08-17	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for appellant's initial brief	motion
13	2016-08-19	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Appellant's Initial Brief)	Extension Granted
14	2016-10-12	Initial Brief - Appellant	appellant\'s initial brief
15	2016-10-12	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by appellant	appellant\'s designation of matter
16	2016-11-10	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Bowers	motion
17	2016-11-10	Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Robert Gantt	motion
18	2016-11-14	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Bobby Bowers	order
19	2016-11-14	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Robert Gantt	order
20	2016-12-14	Initial Brief - Respondent (Robert Gantt)	Respondent\'s Initial Brief
21	2016-12-14	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Respondent Robert Gantt)	Designation of Matter
22	2016-12-19	Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondent's initial brief of Bobby Bowers	Motion for Extension of Time
23	2016-12-20	Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Bobby Bowers	Extension Granted
24	2016-12-21	Correspondence - outgoing (informing respondent of the correct caption)	Deficiency Letter
25	2016-12-22	Initial Brief - Reply of Appellant to Respondent Robert Gantt	appellant\'s initial reply brief
26	2016-12-28	Correspondence - Incoming (Other) amended proof of service filed by Mr. Cromer	correspondence
27	2016-12-28	Initial Brief - Respondent Bobby Bowers	respondent\'s initial brief
28	2016-12-28	Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent Bowers	respondent\'s designation of matter
29	2017-01-03	Initial Brief - Reply of Appellant to Respondent Bowers	appellant\'s initial reply brief
30	2017-02-02	Record - Record on Appeal Filed	record on appeal volume 1 record on appeal volume 2 record on appeal volume 3 record on appeal volume 4 proof of service of the record on appeal certificate of counsel
31	2017-02-08	Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal (Supplmental)	proof of service of the supplemental record on appeal
32	2017-02-08	Record - Supplemental	record on appeal (supplemental) certificate of counsel
33	2017-02-13	Final Brief - Respondent Robert Gantt	respondent\'s final brief
34	2017-02-15	Final Brief - Appellant	appellant\'s final brief Proof of Service certificate of counsel
35	2017-02-15	Final Brief - Reply to Respondent Bower's Brief	appellant\'s final reply brief Proof of Service certificate of counsel
36	2017-02-15	Final Brief - Reply to Respondent Gantt's Brief	appellant\'s final reply brief Proof of Service certificate of counsel
37	2017-02-21	Final Brief - Respondent Bobby Merle Bowers	respondent\'s final brief Proof of Service
38	2017-04-10	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Respondent's Final Brief - Robert Gantt)	Deficiency Letter for Respondent\'s Final Brief - Robert Gantt
39	2017-04-10	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Record on Appeal)	Record on Appeal Deficiency Letter
40	2017-04-10	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Appellant's Final Brief)	Appellant\'s Final Brief Deficiency Letter
41	2017-04-10	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Final Reply - Bobby Merle Bowers)	Deficiency Letter for Respondent\'s Final Brief - Bobby Merle Bowers
42	2017-04-10	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Final Reply - Gantt)	Deficiency Letter for Final Reply - Gantt
43	2017-04-10	Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Supplemental Record)	Supplemental Record Deficiency Letter
44	2017-04-13	Deficiency - Correction (Final Reply - Gantt)	certificate of counsel
45	2017-04-13	Deficiency - Correction (Record on Appeal)	certificate of counsel
46	2017-04-13	Deficiency - Correction (Appellants Final Brief)	certifcate of counsel
47	2017-04-13	Deficiency - Correction (Supplemental Record)	certificate of counsel
48	2017-04-13	Deficiency - Correction (Final Reply - Bobby Merle Bowers)	certificate of counsel
49	2017-05-02	Final Brief - Briefing and Record Complete	Record on Appeal Vol. 1 (Amended) Record on Appeal Vol. 2 (Amended) Record on Appeal Vol. 3 (Amended) Record on Appeal Vol. 4 (Amended) Appellant\'s Final Brief (Amended) Respondent\'s Final Brief (Bowers) Respondent\'s Final Brief (Robert Gantt) Appellant\'s Final Reply Brief (Gantt) Appellant\'s Final Reply Brief (Bowers) Supplemental Record on Appeal (Amended)
50	2017-11-08	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)	Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments
51	2017-11-13	Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)	Frawley--no March conflicts
52	2017-11-14	Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)	Montgomery--no March conflicts
53	2017-12-06	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)	Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments
54	2018-03-02	Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Oral Argument and Acknowledgement)	Letter - Notice of Oral Argument and Acknowledgement
55	2018-03-02	Oral Argument - Removed from Roster	—
56	2018-03-06	Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)	Signed Acknowledgment- Michael H. Montgomery Signed Acknowledgment- Patrick J. Frawley
57	2018-03-08	Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)	Signed Acknowledgment- J. Lewis Cromer
58	2018-03-08	Correspondence - Incoming (Other) notice of appearance of Elizabeth M. Bowen, Esquire	correspondence
59	2018-03-08	Correspondence - Incoming (Other) notice of appearance of J. Paul Porter, Esquire	correspondence
60	2018-03-27	Oral Argument - Removed from Roster	—
61	2018-03-27	Correspondence - Incoming (Other) confirmation from counsel Patrick Frawley (oral argument cancelled)	correspondence (email)
62	2018-03-27	Correspondence - Incoming (Other) email from Michael Montgomery confirming receipt of notice of cancellation of oral argument	correspondence (email)
63	2018-03-27	Correspondence - Outgoing (Oral argument cancelled) parties notified via email and US Mail	correspondence
64	2018-04-02	Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Submission)	Letter
65	2018-10-31	Dispositional Decision - Opinion	18-UP-403 - Kim Murphy v. Richland Lexington School District No. 5 (2).docx cover letter
66	2018-11-16	Remittitur - Remittitur Sent	remittitur
67	2018-11-19	Motion - Costs filed on behalf of Respondent Robert Gantt	motion
68	2018-12-06	Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion for costs	order

1

2016-06-06

Notice of Appeal (Civil) - Initial

notice of appeal order under appeal order under appeal

2

2016-06-07

Transcript Documents - Transcript Ordered

letter ordering the transcript from the court reporter (1 of 2) letter ordering the transcript from the court reporter (2 of 2)

3

2016-06-09

Correspondence - Incoming (Other) agreement to dismiss party

correspondence

4

2016-06-10

Correspondence - Outgoing notice of appeal initial letter

notice of appeal initial letter

5

2016-06-28

Deficiency - Correction - proof of service of agreement to dismiss party

deficiency correction (proof of service)

6

2016-07-28

Non-Dispositional Decision - Order dismissing Richland Lexington School District No.5 Board of Trustees as a party to this appeal.

order

7

2016-07-28

Non-Dispositional Decision - Order denying motion to consolidate / motion filed in case # 2016-000211

order

8

2016-08-03

Motion - Relieve / Withdraw / Substitute as Counsel

motion

9

2016-08-08

Transcript Documents - Notification that Transcript has not been Received

correspondence

10

2016-08-15

Transcript Documents - Transcript Delivered - Direct Appeal

letter confirming receipt of the transcript

11

2016-08-15

Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion

order cover letter

12

2016-08-17

Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for appellant's initial brief

motion

13

2016-08-19

Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted (Appellant's Initial Brief)

Extension Granted

14

2016-10-12

Initial Brief - Appellant

appellant\'s initial brief

15

2016-10-12

Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by appellant

appellant\'s designation of matter

16

2016-11-10

Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Bowers

motion

17

2016-11-10

Motion - Extension of Time (1st) for respondent's initial brief of Robert Gantt

motion

18

2016-11-14

Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Bobby Bowers

order

19

2016-11-14

Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Robert Gantt

order

20

2016-12-14

Initial Brief - Respondent (Robert Gantt)

Respondent\'s Initial Brief

21

2016-12-14

Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed (Respondent Robert Gantt)

Designation of Matter

22

2016-12-19

Motion - Extension of Time (2nd) for respondent's initial brief of Bobby Bowers

Motion for Extension of Time

23

2016-12-20

Non-Dispositional Decision - Extension Granted for respondent's initial brief of Bobby Bowers

Extension Granted

24

2016-12-21

Correspondence - outgoing (informing respondent of the correct caption)

Deficiency Letter

25

2016-12-22

Initial Brief - Reply of Appellant to Respondent Robert Gantt

appellant\'s initial reply brief

26

2016-12-28

Correspondence - Incoming (Other) amended proof of service filed by Mr. Cromer

correspondence

27

2016-12-28

Initial Brief - Respondent Bobby Bowers

respondent\'s initial brief

28

2016-12-28

Designation of Matter - Designation of Matter Filed by Respondent Bowers

respondent\'s designation of matter

29

2017-01-03

Initial Brief - Reply of Appellant to Respondent Bowers

appellant\'s initial reply brief

30

2017-02-02

Record - Record on Appeal Filed

record on appeal volume 1 record on appeal volume 2 record on appeal volume 3 record on appeal volume 4 proof of service of the record on appeal certificate of counsel

31

2017-02-08

Record - Proof of Service of Record on Appeal (Supplmental)

proof of service of the supplemental record on appeal

32

2017-02-08

Record - Supplemental

record on appeal (supplemental) certificate of counsel

33

2017-02-13

Final Brief - Respondent Robert Gantt

respondent\'s final brief

34

2017-02-15

Final Brief - Appellant

appellant\'s final brief Proof of Service certificate of counsel

35

2017-02-15

Final Brief - Reply to Respondent Bower's Brief

appellant\'s final reply brief Proof of Service certificate of counsel

36

2017-02-15

Final Brief - Reply to Respondent Gantt's Brief

appellant\'s final reply brief Proof of Service certificate of counsel

37

2017-02-21

Final Brief - Respondent Bobby Merle Bowers

respondent\'s final brief Proof of Service

38

2017-04-10

Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Respondent's Final Brief - Robert Gantt)

Deficiency Letter for Respondent\'s Final Brief - Robert Gantt

39

2017-04-10

Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Record on Appeal)

Record on Appeal Deficiency Letter

40

2017-04-10

Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Appellant's Final Brief)

Appellant\'s Final Brief Deficiency Letter

41

2017-04-10

Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Final Reply - Bobby Merle Bowers)

Deficiency Letter for Respondent\'s Final Brief - Bobby Merle Bowers

42

2017-04-10

Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Final Reply - Gantt)

Deficiency Letter for Final Reply - Gantt

43

2017-04-10

Deficiency - Deficiency Letter Sent (Supplemental Record)

Supplemental Record Deficiency Letter

44

2017-04-13

Deficiency - Correction (Final Reply - Gantt)

certificate of counsel

45

2017-04-13

Deficiency - Correction (Record on Appeal)

certificate of counsel

46

2017-04-13

Deficiency - Correction (Appellants Final Brief)

certifcate of counsel

47

2017-04-13

Deficiency - Correction (Supplemental Record)

certificate of counsel

48

2017-04-13

Deficiency - Correction (Final Reply - Bobby Merle Bowers)

certificate of counsel

49

2017-05-02

Final Brief - Briefing and Record Complete

Record on Appeal Vol. 1 (Amended) Record on Appeal Vol. 2 (Amended) Record on Appeal Vol. 3 (Amended) Record on Appeal Vol. 4 (Amended) Appellant\'s Final Brief (Amended) Respondent\'s Final Brief (Bowers) Respondent\'s Final Brief (Robert Gantt) Appellant\'s Final Reply Brief (Gantt) Appellant\'s Final Reply Brief (Bowers) Supplemental Record on Appeal (Amended)

50

2017-11-08

Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)

Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments

51

2017-11-13

Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)

Frawley--no March conflicts

52

2017-11-14

Correspondence - Incoming (Response to Preliminary List)

Montgomery--no March conflicts

53

2017-12-06

Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments)

Letter - Conflict Letter for Oral Arguments

54

2018-03-02

Correspondence - Outgoing (Letter - Notice of Oral Argument and Acknowledgement)

Letter - Notice of Oral Argument and Acknowledgement

55

2018-03-02

Oral Argument - Removed from Roster

—

56

2018-03-06

Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)

Signed Acknowledgment- Michael H. Montgomery Signed Acknowledgment- Patrick J. Frawley

57

2018-03-08

Correspondence - Incoming (Signed Acknowledgment)

Signed Acknowledgment- J. Lewis Cromer

58

2018-03-08

Correspondence - Incoming (Other) notice of appearance of Elizabeth M. Bowen, Esquire

correspondence

59

2018-03-08

Correspondence - Incoming (Other) notice of appearance of J. Paul Porter, Esquire

correspondence

60

2018-03-27

Oral Argument - Removed from Roster

—

61

2018-03-27

Correspondence - Incoming (Other) confirmation from counsel Patrick Frawley (oral argument cancelled)

correspondence (email)

62

2018-03-27

Correspondence - Incoming (Other) email from Michael Montgomery confirming receipt of notice of cancellation of oral argument

correspondence (email)

63

2018-03-27

Correspondence - Outgoing (Oral argument cancelled) parties notified via email and US Mail

correspondence

64

2018-04-02

Correspondence - Outgoing (Notice of Submission)

Letter

65

2018-10-31

Dispositional Decision - Opinion

18-UP-403 - Kim Murphy v. Richland Lexington School District No. 5 (2).docx cover letter

66

2018-11-16

Remittitur - Remittitur Sent

remittitur

67

2018-11-19

Motion - Costs filed on behalf of Respondent Robert Gantt

motion

68

2018-12-06

Non-Dispositional Decision - Order granting motion for costs

order

Lower Court / Tribunal	—
Case Group	Appeal	Initial Docket Date	2016-06-06
Case Type	Common Pleas	Case Subtype	Other
Filed Date	—	Argument Date	—
Disposition Date	—	Remittitur Date	—
Last Action Event	2018-12-06

2016-001198

Case Info